In its judgement, decided on the 23 March 2022, in the names of
Adrian Muscat vs. Matthew Agius, the Court of Appeal in its
inferior jurisdiction (the “Court of
Appeal”), delivered by Judge Lawrence Mintoff,
considered a case on libel and defamation following the decision of
the Court of Magistrates on 14 June 2021 (the “Court
of First InstanceThe facts of the case were as
follows:
On 24 August 2016, Mr. Agius published a news article in a local
newspaper which referred to the claimant, Mr. Muscat, and his
brother. The subject of the news article mentioned Mr. Muscat and
his brother in the context of alleged attempted insurance fraud and
road rage threats (the “News
Article”). Mr. Muscat then proceeded to file a case
in the Court of First Instance to claim compensation for damages
and for the court to declare that the News Article was defamatory
and libellous.