Facts
The case concerned an application for leave to appeal against a
decision in the Royal Court striking out a claim against Maison
Anley Property Nominee Limited ("MA"). The conclusion
arrived at by the Royal Court was upheld, that being the claim
contained no cause of action.
Background
Oleg Chvetsov (the "Plaintiff"), as
settlor, established a Jersey discretionary trust, of which he was
also one of the beneficiaries. The trustee in this case (the
"Trustee") was the sole trustee of the
trust, and held through MA (its nominee) a North London property
(the "Property") occupied by the
Plaintiff and his family.
The Plaintiff requested and the Trustee agreed to renovations at
the Property, and the Trustee authorised MA to enter into a
contract with a firm of architects to design and supervise the
renovations. The claim put forward originally by the Plaintiff was
against both the Trustee and MA, alleging that both parties had
failed in monitoring and