In the recent decision of The Representation of Vistra
Fiduciary Limited [2022] JRC 164, the Royal Court moved
away from the Court of Appeal's preferred test for
rectification of a trust instrument set out in B&C v
Virtue Trustees (Switzerland) AG [2018] JCA 219, and
reaffirmed the well-established three stage test
in Walbrook Trustees v Amethyst Trust [2002] JRC
186 and R.E. Sesemann Will Trust [2005] JLR 421.
In doing so, the Royal Court considered that it was not "bound
by the propositions of law" referred to by the Court of Appeal
as they were not the subject of argument by the parties before the
court.
This is a significant decision for trust practitioners to be
aware of, and a salutary reminder to ensure that a trust instrument
aligns with the intention of the Settlor. It is also a rare example
of the Royal Court moving away from a decision by the Court of
Appeal.