You pays your money and takes your choice –
Tenant's liability for service charge
Q: If a tenant has the right to use part of a building under the
terms of his lease but doesn't, is he still required to
contribute towards its maintenance? A: In short, 'yes'.
In Reekie v Oakwood Court Residents Association [2023]
UKUT 45 (LC) the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) (UT) was
asked to determine whether a long leaseholder was obliged by the
terms of his lease to contribute towards the cost of refurbishing a
lift he claimed not to use.
Background: Mr Reekie had long leases of the
Flats numbered 1, 2 and 5 Oakwood Court in Eastbourne. The building
was a large Victorian House which had been converted in the late
1980s to create eight self-contained flats: two were on the ground
floor and three were on each of the upper two floors. Prior to Mr
Reekie's acquisition, Flats 1, 2 and 5 were converted to form a
single dwelling occupying most of the ground floor and part of