It is not uncommon we see small to medium size cargo claims
coming before the Hong Kong High Court, notwithstanding our
District Court seizes jurisdiction on claims up to HKD1
million.
The argument has always been that, such was the purpose of the
Admiralty Court (a division of the High Court), to handle complex
shipping cases regardless of value. Recently in Morpol SA v Blue
Anchor Line [2017] 4 HKC 165, Lam J ruled that a cargo claim worth
HKD629,000 brought before the Admiralty Court, even involving
application of the Hague Visby Rules, is not "complex or
important" enough to justify a refusal to transfer the case to
the District Court.
This could mean a small victory for the defence, because of the
lower recoverable hourly rates for a solicitor: under the current
regime (last revised in 1997) it is a maximum HKD4,000 for High
Court cases for a 10+ year qualified solicitor, compared to
HKD2,600 for handling the matter at District Court. Similarly, for
a 2-4