Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 19 JULY 2011

Are You Acting Within The 'Band Of Reasonable Responses’?

Collas Crill
Collas Crill
Contributor
Collas Crill

Collas Crill

Firm Details: Chief Executive Officer: Jason Romer Managing Partners: Bermuda: Lilla Zuill, BVI:...

View firm profile
Explore more from Collas Crill

In a recent decision Guernsey’s Employment and Discrimination Tribunal dismissed an applicant’s claim for unfair dismissal and held that the respondent employer had acted reasonably in treating the applicant’s misconduct as a sufficient reason for his dismissal.

GuernseyWealth Management

In a recent decision Guernsey's Employment and Discrimination Tribunal dismissed an applicant's claim for unfair dismissal and held that the respondent employer had acted reasonably in treating the applicant's misconduct as a sufficient reason for his dismissal.

In this case the applicant, a former head gardener of the respondent's premises, brought an action against the respondent claiming that he had been unfairly dismissed when he suffered an injury at work and was expected to work whilst being 'signed off' as medically unfit.

The respondent successfully defended the claim arguing that the applicant was dismissed not because of any alleged injury but because of his persistent breaches of the express and implied terms of his contract of employment. The Tribunal accepted the respondent's evidence that over the 18 months of his employment, the applicant continually took extended lunch breaks, arrived late at work and regularly left early, failed to properly inform

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from