Introduction
In a recent preliminary reference judgment dated October 4, 2024
in the names Real Madrid Club de Fútbol, AE v EE,
Société Éditrice du Monde SA (CJEU
C-633/2022), the European Court of Justice (ECJ) issued a
ruling highlighting the balance between defamation damages, press
freedom and the recognition and enforcement of judgments in civil
and commercial matters.
The ECJ ruled that the recognition and enforcement of a Spanish
Judgment obtained by Spanish football team Real Madrid in Spain,
against French Newspaper Le Monde in France, containing
excessive defamation damages could breach press freedom and
fundamental freedoms and may thus be refused by the French Courts,
through the invocation of the "public policy"
exception under the Brussels I Regulation (now replaced by Brussels
I Recast – Regulation (EU) No 1215/2012).