Section 2778 of the Civil Code of Quebec provides that a creditor must obtain the authorization of the court in order to take property in payment when the debtor has discharged half or more than half of the secured obligation.
Until very recently, "half of the secured obligation" referred solely to the unpaid portion of the principal. A recent decision from the Court of Appeal alters this interpretation. In the CIBC Mortgage Corporation vs. Vasquez decision, rendered on April 10, 2000, the Court of Appeal by a majority decided that the secured obligation includes not only the principal, but also the interest and costs associated to it.
1. Court Of Appeal Decision
In April 1986, the lender had granted a hypothecary loan in the amount of $40,800, bearing interest at a rate of 11% per annum payable in monthly instalments. Following several renewals of the loan, the debtor defaulted in June 1997. At that time, the debtor had paid a total amount of $51,189, of which $6,860 was in