The Supreme Court of Canada released its
decision1 on the constitutionality of
the Greenhouse Gas Pollution Pricing
Act2 (the
"GGPPA" or the
"Act") on March 25, 2021, marking an end
to the multi-year and multi-province litigation.
The federal government enacted the GGPPA in
2018 and provincial governments quickly stepped forward to
challenge its validity in the courts. The reference began in the
Court of Appeal of Saskatchewan and was heard on February 13 and
14, 2019.3 Subsequent references were brought in
two more provinces, Ontario4 and
Alberta.5 The appeal of all three Court of Appeal
decisions was heard by the Supreme Court on September 22 and 23,
2020.
The Supreme Court, with a divided 6-3 bench, found the Act
constitutional. One justice dissented in part, finding that the
federal government could legislate in the area but that the Act as
currently formulated is too broad. The other two dissenters found,
each on their own reasons, that the Act was