Lawyer's use of AI program confirms its unreliability
A New York lawyer was embarrassed to admit using artificial
intelligence (AI) program ChatGPT when preparing his courtroom
legal argument, after it was exposed to have cited several court
cases that didn't exist.
When the judge and opponent lawyers couldn't find the cases,
the lawyer discovered ChatGPT had simply made up six judgments that
would favour his argument.
The judge was damning - condemning the lawyer for citing
"bogus judicial decisions, with bogus quotes and bogus
internal citations".
The US lawyer, who had 30 years' experience but had never
used ChatGPT before, was apologetic, saying he had even asked the
program if the cases were real, and it had replied "yes".
(Please see A lawyer used ChatGPT and now has to answer for
its 'bogus' citations, The Verge, 28 May
2023.)