ARTICLE · 23 OCTOBER 2024

Market Intelligence Thought Leadership Award Winner

AI-generated evidence controversy in Federal Court

O'Brien Criminal & Civil Solicitors

Explore more from O'Brien Criminal & Civil Solicitors

Recent case highlights the potential risks of using AI tools in legal practice without proper oversight.

AustraliaTechnology

Author LinkedIn connections

In a recent family law case in the Federal Circuit and Family Court, a major issue arose. A lawyer submitted AI-generated evidence! It included a list of case authorities that turned out to be completely fabricated by an AI tool.

The presiding judge, Justice James Turnbull, became suspicious when he couldn't locate several of the cited cases in legal databases. This prompted him an investigation into the matter.

Investigation and Revelation: AI-generated evidence

The truth was quickly uncovered. Apparently, the lawyer used ChatGPT, a large language model AI, to generate the case authorities.

Finally, the lawyer admitted that she hadn't independently verified the cases but believed they were real. This revelation raised serious concerns about the reliability of AI-generated evidence. Additionally, it highlighted the potential risks of using such tools in legal practice without proper oversight.

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

Register for freeORLog in

Related Articles

Cyber Security: A Month In Retrospect (Australia) - September 2026

AustraliaTechnology

Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer LLP

Artificial Intelligence In Healthcare: Navigating Legal And Regulatory Challenges

AustraliaTechnology

Cross Examining Cyber EP28: Cross Examining Charles Carmakal (Podcast)

AustraliaTechnology

Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer LLP

AI Notetaker Tools In Australian Workforces: The Hidden Legal Risks Organisations Cannot Ignore

AustraliaTechnology

Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer LLP

Context Is Centre Stage: Key Takeaways From ALPMA 2026

AustraliaTechnology

Legal Intelligence Newsletters: sign up for the latest legal and regulatory news on your chosen topics

Read more about

Related Comparative Guides

Comparative Guide

Blockchain & Crypto Assets

Comparative Guide

Artificial Intelligence

Comparative Guide

Fintech

See more popular content from

Technology

AI Sexual Deepfake Images And Audio Laws, Offences And Penalties

Recently, the NSW Government passed the Crimes Amendment (Intimate Image and Audio Material) Act 2025 (NSW) to strengthen protections against the non-consensual recording...

AustraliaTechnology

Criminal Defence Lawyers Australia

Australia's AI Infrastructure Consultation: Proposed Standards For Data Centres And Frontier AI

The Australian Government has released a consultation paper proposing national mandatory minimum standards for data centres (Consultation Paper), as part of its broader AI standards initiative.

AustraliaTechnology

Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer LLP

Fair Work Commission’s New Powers To Handle AI-generated Claims: What Employers Need To Know

From 20 October 2026, a new Fair Work Commission (FWC) Guidance Note will address the growing use of generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) in proceedings. It comes as a self-represented litigant credits an ‘AI legal team’ with helping him secure a landmark FWC win.

AustraliaTechnology

AI Governance: ASIC And APRA Letters To Industry On Emerging AI Risks

The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) has issued an open letter to all AFS licensees and market participants calling for urgent action to strengthen cyber resilience in response to the evolving threat posed by artificial intelligence models (the ASIC Letter).

AustraliaTechnology

Corrs Chambers Westgarth

APRA v Bedingo And Adelaide Bank: A Wake-up Call For Directors And Officers

The Australian Prudential and Regulatory Authority has launched unprecedented civil penalty proceedings against Bendigo and Adelaide Bank following a 2023 cybersecurity breach that exposed critical weaknesses in the bank's risk management systems. This landmark case signals a fundamental shift in regulatory enforcement, extending accountability beyond corporate entities to individual directors and officers who fail to ensure adequate cybersecurity controls are functioning as intended.

AustraliaTechnology

Mandatory reporting of ransomware payments may soon be law. What you need to know

Government introduced into Parliament legislation to create a standalone Cyber Security Act.

AustraliaTechnology

Cryptocurrency Regulation In Australia: Understanding The New Digital Assets Framework

The Corporations Amendment (Digital Assets Framework) Bill 2025 (Cth) (the Bill) marks a significant step in bridging digital asset intermediaries within Australia’s financial services regime.

AustraliaTechnology

ASIC Demands Urgent Cyber Upgrades To Combat Frontier AI Security Threats

In an open letter published on 8 May 2026, ASIC, who are responsible for regulating Australia's corporate, financial services and insurance sectors, urged Australian financial services licence (AFSL) holders to act promptly against the risks posed by advanced AI systems. ASIC warned that malicious actors are increasingly using cutting-edge AI models to identify and exploit vulnerabilities at an unprecedented scale.

AustraliaTechnology

Use AI And Lose Privilege?

Generative AI can be a valuable tool in legal practice, but using public AI platforms with confidential or privileged information can create significant risks. We examine two recent overseas decisions and what they may mean for Australian businesses, insurers and lawyers when it comes to preserving legal professional privilege and maintaining confidentiality.

AustraliaTechnology

Gilchrist Connell

South Australian Royal Commission Into Artificial Intelligence: What Businesses Need To Know Now

South Australia has announced a Royal Commission into Artificial Intelligence, set to commence in October 2026 and deliver findings by July 2027. The inquiry will examine AI's economic and social impacts across policy, education, public services, workforce transformation, and infrastructure. Businesses using or developing AI should prepare for potential regulatory reforms and consider engaging with the inquiry process.

AustraliaTechnology