Rising Stars

Dispute resolution in New Zealand

Bell Gully

The ‘truly collaborative legal team’ at Bell Gully is praised for its ability to ‘cover a wide range of tricky issues’ across a host of complex commercial disputes. Counting large New Zealand corporates, financial institutions, and government agencies among its key clients, the team’s caseload regularly includes class actions, regulatory investigations and disputes, construction disputes, defamation and media disputes, and white collar crime cases. Leading the department is Sophie East , who has particular expertise in class actions, banking and finance litigation, arbitration, and all aspects of corporate disputes. East is supported by Wellington-based deputy leader Rachael Brown, who specialises in public law, including Māori legal issues, as well as employment law. David Friar, lauded by clients for his ‘depth of enquiry and understanding’ and strong courtroom advocacy, focuses on complex commercial disputes, insurance litigation, and corporate and insolvency disputes. Jenny Stevens is a key contact for competition law-related disputes and other sector specific economic regulation, while Kirsty Dobbs is recommended for her expertise in contract and construction disputes. The ‘hard-working’ Tim Fitzgerald is a key port of call for retail banks, listed entities, and other corporate and insolvency practitioners on some of their most complex disputes. Blair Keown specialises in contentious issues relating to the financial markets, while Jesse Wilson is particularly experienced in takeovers and securities law.

Practice head(s):

Sophie East; Rachael Brown


Other key lawyers:

David Friar; Jenny Stevens; Tim Fitzgerald; Jesse Wilson; Brad Ward; Blair Keown; Kirsty Dobbs; Sam Hiebendaal


Testimonials

‘Good balance of skills, particularly at senior associate level. Able to cover a wide range of tricky issues and draft precise submissions with and without the assistance of senior counsel.’

‘Tim Fitzgerald is hard working, calm and approachable.’

‘Sam Hiebendaal is a very talented individual and careful thinker with insightful submissions.’

Key clients

Air New Zealand


ANZ Bank


ASB Bank


Auckland City Council


Calibre Partners


Carter Holt Harvey


Cigna Life Insurance


Department of Corrections


Downer Group NZ


Electricity Authority


Frucor Suntory NZ


Genesis Energy


IAG New Zealand


Kāinga Ora – Homes and Communities


NZME


Pharmac


Port Marlborough


PricewaterhouseCoopers


Salvation Army


Stride Property


Suncorp Group


Te Pūkenga – New Zealand Institute of Skills and Technology


Te Rūnanga o Ngāi Tahu


The Fletcher Construction Company


Wellington City Council


Xero


Te Pūkenga – New Zealand Institute of Skills and Technology


Work highlights


  • Acting for ANZ Bank New Zealand in the largest class action in New Zealand to date (by number of claimants) in respect of alleged breaches by ANZ of disclosure requirements under the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Act 2003.
  • Acting for ASX-listed company AWN Holdings in a high-profile class action brought by investors in relation to the Initial Public Offering of the formerly NZX-listed Intueri Education Group Ltd.
  • Acted for Millennium & Copthorne in the Supreme Court in respect of an application for judicial review of a decision by the Auckland Council to impose a targeted rate on property used for commercial accommodation.

Chapman Tripp

Chapman Tripp boasts an esteemed team of highly regarded partners and is noted for its leading expertise in intellectual property, climate change, construction, and class action disputes. The team is well-positioned to advise its diverse roster of clients, comprising off-shore multinationals and New Zealand entities, such as Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei Trust, on significant commercial disputes before all levels of court. The practice is steered by Justin Graham, who has extensive expertise in defamation, privacy, patent, copyright, and trade mark litigation. Consultant John McKay is a key contact for clients hailing from the construction sector, including contractors, principals, engineers, financiers, suppliers, and manufacturers. Laura Fraser advises clients on a broad range of contentious corporate and regulatory breach issues, while Nicola Swan is noted for her experience before international arbitral tribunals and in domestic courts.

Practice head(s):

Justin Graham


Other key lawyers:

Laura Fraser; John McKay; Michael Arthur; Tim Smith; Nicola Swan; Edward Scorgie


Key clients

Fonterra Co-operative Group


Former directors of Mainzeal Property & Construction Limited (Mainzeal)


Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei Trust


Mercury NZ


Waka Kotahi NZ Transport Agency


Solomon Islands Electricity Authority


Chorus New Zealand Limited


Local Government New Zealand


Fisher & Paykel Healthcare Limited


Calibre Partners


LeeSalmonLong

Housing a ‘first-class’ team, boutique firm LeeSalmonLong is praised for its ‘laser focus’ and ‘excellent mix of academic understanding and practical skills’. Based in Auckland, the practice counts major corporates, NGOs and political organisations among its key client base, all benefitting from the team’s experience in leading witness trials and appeals, including appearing before the Supreme Court. Pro-bono matters form a prominent part of the practice, which advises some of the world’s leading institutional organisations. The ‘personable’ Michael Heard is noted for his commercial, contractual, and contentious insolvency work, while the ‘brilliant’ Tim Mullins consistently appears at all levels of the higher courts and certain specialised tribunals. ‘Polished performer’ Rachel Keane is praised for her ‘excellent client and witness management skills’. Daniel Nilsson has a specialist media law practice, regularly acting for both media organisations and individuals in defamation cases, while David Bullock has particular expertise in company and contractual disputes. Isaac Hikaka has left the firm to join the bar.

Practice head(s):

Michael Heard; Tim Mullins; Rachel Keane; Daniel Nilsson; David Bullock


Testimonials

‘Absolutely first-class litigation firm.’

‘Rachel Keane is a polished performer, with excellent client and witness management skills. Daniel Nilsson is the leading defamation solicitor in New Zealand with a practice second to none.’

‘I recommend all the partners. David Bullock is one of the most brilliant lawyers I have ever worked with. Michael Heard is capable of managing complex and large cases with a remarkable grasp of detail. Tim Mullins is an excellent strategic lawyer, especially in competition, IP and regulatory contexts.’

Key clients

Stuff


TVNZ


Orbis Blockchain Technologies Ltd


Shane Dromgool and others


Greenpeace Aotearoa Inc


Aotearoa Water Action Inc


MinterEllisonRuddWatts

Well-regarded for its ‘wide range of knowledge’ and ability to ‘provide a solution to complex problems’, the team at MinterEllisonRuddWatts regularly acts on critical and high-profile commercial litigation for large corporates and financial institutions. The practice offers expertise across the full spectrum of commercial litigation matters, including banking, environmental, insolvency, technology, and insurance-related disputes. In Wellington, Richard Gordon, who is a key port of call to New Zealand’s main trading banks, jointly leads the practice alongside Auckland-based Gillian Service, who specialises in people risk management for businesses. The ‘very acute and intelligent’ Jane Standage is regularly instructed on some of New Zealand’s most complex litigation and is lauded by clients for her ‘excellent judgement’. Andrew Horne is noted for his expertise in commercial disputes, corporate and regulatory issues, and technology-related disputes, while the ‘outstanding’ Stacey Shortall is frequently instructed to conduct internal reviews and self-assessments for clients and their boards. Nick Frith is another key contact, recommended for his focus on insurance disputes across all areas of the industry. Senior associate Olivia De Pont is also recommended.

Practice head(s):

Richard Gordon; Gillian Service


Other key lawyers:

Jane Standage; Stacey Shortall; Nick Frith; Andrew Horne; Sean Gollin; Briony Davies; Aaron Lloyd; Olivia De Pont


Testimonials

‘The firm has a wide range of knowledge and skills to handle all aspects and can always provide a solution to complex problems.’

‘They are real professionals with great judgement. They take the good points, leave the bad ones, and are excellent to deal with.’

‘They fight hard for their clients but are cooperative towards getting disputes heard and pragmatic in a search for a commercial resolution. Very impressive all round.’

‘Jane Standage is very acute and intelligent, firm when needed, but always respectful and good to deal with. She has excellent judgement and knows the good points in a case instinctively. I think she will become one of the best commercial litigation solicitors in Auckland and very soon.’

‘We use the Minters team for specialist HSE legal advice. We think they are best in class.’

‘Stacey Shortall is outstanding and, in our experience, the best HSE lawyer we have dealt with.’

‘They identify the people who are best able to provide a solution.’

‘Nick Frith continues to grow in stature within the market.’

Key clients

Bathurst Resources Limited


viagogo AG


PricewaterhouseCoopers


Manawa Energy Ltd


Westpac Bank New Zealand


Rabobank New Zealand


Bank of New Zealand


Beach Energy Resources NZ (Kupe) Limited


Channel Infrastructure NZ Limited


Te Tari Taiwhenua | Department of Internal Affairs


Work highlights


  • Acting for Bathurst Resources Limited successfully in the leading contract interpretation case heard by the New Zealand Supreme Court in relation to a USD40m claim.
  • Acting for viagogo in High Court proceedings brought by the Commerce Commission, the first time the NZCC has issued proceedings against a wholly overseas-based online business and is part of a wider suite of litigation against viagogo internationally.
  • Acted for Beach Energy against Genesis Energy Ltd. successfully on a high-profile NZD150m arbitration.

Simpson Grierson

Highly regarded for its ‘high standard of advice’ and ‘practically balanced’ approach, Simpson Grierson's litigation practice works with large New Zealand companies and international businesses on complex commercial, regulatory, and public law proceedings. The practice houses an ‘expert team’ that possesses capabilities across a wide variety of disputes, including class actions and litigation funding, data protection, media, IP and corporate governance-related cases. Practice head John Shackleton acts on major commercial and public law arbitrations, regularly assisting clients with resolving disputes through mediation and negotiated settlements. Key contact Anne Callinan has a particular focus on competition, consumer, and financial markets law, regularly assisting clients in relation to numerous investigations and civil and criminal proceedings. Jania Baigent acts on major commercial cases involving complex contractual, tortious, fair trading, and intellectual property disputes, while Richard Lange is a key port of call for major corporate, local authority, and private individual clients on a range of commercial disputes.

Practice head(s):

John Shackleton


Other key lawyers:

Richard Lange; John Shackleton; Anne Callinan; Helen Smith; Nina Blomfield; Jania Baigent


Testimonials

‘This practice is unique in the incredibly high standard of advice that they provide. Their specialists are go-to experts both at the local and national level.’

‘The Simpson Grierson team has, at all times, functioned as an expert team. That is, they have bought together a great depth of talent with those at all levels of seniority adding significant value to the delivery, under the guidance and leadership of a partner with great skill and organisation.’

‘Their ability to provide advice that is both legally and practically balanced is exceptional. They have not resiled from dealing with the hard issues. ’

Key clients

Financial Markets Authority


Malcolm Keefe and John Moore (former non-executive directors of former ASX-listed Arowana International Limited)


Te Whakakitenga o Waikato Incorporated (Waikato-Tainui)


Auckland Council


Te Whatu Ora


Westpac Banking Corporation


Westpac New Zealand Limited


Fire and Emergency New Zealand


New Zealand Rugby Union


Auckland Transport


Marlborough Lines


City Rail Link and Auckland Council


Christchurch City Council


Energy Beverages LLC


Work highlights


  • Advised the FMA on its nearly two-year investigation and acting for it in two High Court civil proceedings issued in late 2019 against the company and its former directors and chief financial officer.
  • Acted for Te Whatu Ora Health New Zealand and Ministry of Justice in a landmark proceeding against unknown defendants.
  • Acting for Auckland Council in its landmark win in the Supreme Court in defence of judicial review proceedings brought by four large commercial accommodation owners and/or operators challenging the Council’s decision to introduce a targeted rate assessed on commercial accommodation providers.

Anthony Harper

Praised for its ‘exceptional abilities in all aspects of litigation’ Anthony Harper is focused on general commercial litigation, with particular expertise in insurance, health and safety, distressed assets and construction litigation. At the helm sits Dan Hughes, who has a track record of acting on some of the leading construction and insolvency cases in New Zealand. Christchurch-based Peter Woods handles a wide range of mandates, from commercial property and company law disputes, to defamation and IP infringements, while Lynne Van has particular expertise in insolvency and restructuring.

Practice head(s):

Dan Hughes


Other key lawyers:

Peter Woods; Lynne Van


Testimonials

‘Exceptional abilities in all aspects of litigation, as well as being a full service firm, including complex commercial and regulatory litigation, as well as complex high-value private disputes.’

‘The team have strong attributes in all aspects of complex commercial litigation practice.’

‘The strength and depth of the team stands out. The partners are highly regarded and experienced. The senior associates are impressive.’

Key clients

McGrathNicol


Southbase Construction


Argosy Property Limited


White Island Tours Limited


Avior Consulting


MaluafitiLeuluaitumuaTu’isila


Work highlights


  • Acted for the liquidators of CBL Insurance Limited in a claim against the directors and advisors of the company in respect of losses claimed at no less than $320m.
  • Representing White Island Tours in its defence of the charges laid against it by WorkSafe in relation to the Whakaari/White Island eruption.
  • Acted for Southbase Construction in a claim against Alutech in respect of goods and materials that Alutech was holding as sub-contractors in a major construction development project.

Buddle Findlay

Buddle Findlay houses a ‘high quality national litigation team’ across the firm’s Auckland, Christchurch, and Wellington offices and is widely praised for its ‘pragmatic, commercial advice’. The ‘talented’ team expertly handles a wide range of disputes, from financial services and property-related disputes, to insolvency litigation and class actions, among others. The practice is steered by Scott Barker, who has over three decades of experience in commercial and insolvency litigation. Auckland-based David Broadmore is noted for his advocacy skills and commercial judgement, having successfully represented clients in many significant disputes. ‘Very strong performer’ Kelly Paterson specialises in insurance, insolvency, and construction litigation, while Olly Peers acts on a wide range of commercial litigation matters. Liam Edginton departed the practice in August 2023.

Practice head(s):

Scott Barker


Other key lawyers:

Willie Palmer; David Broadmore; Olly Peers; Kelly Paterson


Testimonials

‘A high-quality national litigation team that gives pragmatic commercial advice and provides excellent value for money. The partners are actively involved and accessible, while the juniors and senior associates are talented and well-trained.’

‘David Broadmore has a great depth of knowledge and experience in insolvency, and is wise beyond his years and a safe pair of hands.’

‘Strong litigation partners who regularly appear in court as advocates. Real hands-on experience.’

Key clients

New Zealand Steel


Southern Response Earthquake Services


New Zealand Blood and Organ Service


Grant Thornton New Zealand


Te Whatu Ora – Health New Zealand


MB Technology Ltd


Tuhoe – Te Urewera Trust Board


Buller Electricity


Ashley Trust


PricewaterhouseCoopers


Alan Lun


Dentons New Zealand

‘A sizeable team with good breadth and depth’, Dentons New Zealand's national dispute resolution practice is actively involved in disputes spanning a wide range of areas including, but not limited to, civil, commercial, and competition-related cases, as well as construction and infrastructure, corporate and intellectual property law litigation. In the firm’s Auckland office, practice co-head David Campbell, praised for his ‘exceptional advice and strategic guidance’, specialises in commercial and civil litigation, with a particular focus on competition law, pharmaceuticals product liability, and liability insurance. Wellington-based Hayden Wilson also leads the team and is recommended for his experience handling complex commercial and public law disputes; Wilson has appeared as counsel in the Court of Appeal, High Court, District Court and a range of tribunals. The ‘diligent’ senior Amberley James is also noted.

Practice head(s):

David Campbell; Hayden Wilson


Other key lawyers:

Linda Clark; James McMillan; Patrick Glennie; Jeremy Bell-Connell; Amberley James


Testimonials

‘Dentons make a point of understanding your business and providing valuable advice that will assist, rather than using a ‘one size fits all’ approach. They have extensive knowledge and experience which is invaluable.’

‘David Campbell provided exceptional advice and strategic guidance throughout a long, drawn out dispute. He creates a functioning environment where the less experienced solicitors can do the majority of the work and his oversight ensures quality work is provided.’

‘A sizeable team with good breadth and depth.’

‘James McMillan has been a pleasure to deal with.’

‘Jeremy Bell-Connell is very capable, especially in private wealth disputes, and good to work with.’

‘Amberley James is a stand-out lawyer. She is diligent, personable and switched-on. She’s the person you want on your team.’

‘David Campbell is one of the best lawyers in New Zealand. He is pragmatic, understands the practical aspects of client requirements, and relates well to all manner of clients. He is a pleasure to deal with and, from the client’s perspective, is solutions focused, which is greatly appreciated.’

Key clients

Glidepath


Medical Council of New Zealand


Engineering New Zealand


Deloitte


Rachel McGregor


ANZ


Calibre Partners


Sarsfield Engineering Limited


New Zealand Forest Owners Association


Callin Auto Japan Limited


Earthquake Commission


DLA Piper New Zealand

DLA Piper New Zealand boasts a ‘very strong’ litigation team, praised by clients for its ‘technical expertise’. The firm, noted for its strong global presence, has demonstrable experience in multi-jurisdictional commercial disputes, as well as public law and regulatory proceedings. Practice head Iain Thain, described by one client as ‘one of the best litigation lawyers and advocates in NZ’, specialises in competition and regulatory matters, and has a broad practice in general commercial litigation, encompassing complex contractual disputes and judicial reviews. Alicia Murray is noted for her ‘great expertise and experience in insolvency, competition, and general commercial matters’, while the ‘highly professional’ Emma Moran has a particular focus on commercial litigation, contentious construction, healthcare, and public law disputes.

Practice head(s):

Iain Thain


Other key lawyers:

Alicia Murray; Emma Moran; Cameron McCracken


Testimonials

‘Great team with expertise across disputes in a broad range of fields.’

‘Iain Thain’s expertise in dispute resolution makes him a trusted advisor to our business. Iain’s ability to explain incredibly complex issues in a way that is clear and easy to digest is invaluable.’

‘DLA has a very strong and reputable dispute resolution practice in NZ.’

‘Iain Thain is one of the best litigation lawyers and advocates in NZ. He is incredibly intelligent, logical and creative, and a joy to deal with.’ 

‘Emma Moran has been an absolute pleasure every time we have spoken. She has always been highly professional, considerate, and provided high-quality advice and support to us. She has always provided clear advice and delivered to the timeframes.’

‘The team is extremely easy to work with, and open to working with us in whatever way suits us best in the particular circumstances. Very responsive, and always deliver. It goes without saying that technical expertise is a given.’

‘What makes the DLA team different from their competitors is their willingness to deliver what we need in the way we need it – the team does not impose their standard format or template.’

‘Alicia Murray has great expertise and experience in insolvency, competition, and general commercial matters. She is committed to getting great outcomes for her clients and is a gutsy litigator.’

Key clients

Wakatū Inc


Protalix


Foodstuffs


Cornwall Park Trust Board


Warner Bros. Discovery


Auckland Council


Eke Panuku


Yashili New Zealand Dairy Co Ltd


Dexcom


Moet Hennessey


Du Val Group


Make It 16 Inc


lululemon


Liquorland Ltd


Hungary (the European nation)


AIG Insurance


Tower Insurance


Aon


Steadfast


Apple


Work highlights


  • Represented Make It 16 Inc in obtaining a landmark ruling from the Supreme Court in November 2022 that the existing voting age of 18 amounted to an unjustified limit on the rights of 16 and 17 year olds.
  • Acted for Cornwall Park in a high-profile litigation case regarding the use of the former Auckland Showgrounds site, following the collapse of the Auckland Shows Board due to Covid-19.
  • Acted for Yashili International Dairy Co., Ltd in a contractual dispute between two commercial parties to a contract for the production of infant formula products.

Gilbert Walker

‘Top litigation boutique’ Gilbert Walker is praised by clients for its ‘uniform high quality amongst its partners and associates’. The team serves a diverse roster of clients, comprising major corporates, banks, professional firms, and insurers. Matthew Harris, Iva Rosic, and Martin Smith collectively lead the practice from its Auckland office. The ‘commercial and robust’ Harris regularly appears as lead counsel in first instance and appellate hearings, including against parties represented by Queen’s Counsel, while the ‘outstanding’ Rosic has particular expertise in large-scale commercial disputes, regulatory investigations and insurance litigation. Smith is a key port of call for clients seeking assistance at trial and in other defended hearings and appeals.

Practice head(s):

Matthew Harris; Iva Rosic; Martin Smith


Other key lawyers:

Hamish McQueen; Zoe Brentnall


Testimonials

‘Gilbert Walker is the top litigation boutique in the country with an exceptionally strong team of partners and associates.’

‘They are a fantastic team in the thoroughness of their preparation, their grasp of the facts and the issues and the relevance of the litigation in New Zealand to parallel litigation in other jurisdictions, their willingness to pull out every stop, and the speed and accuracy of their work.’

‘I have worked with all the partners – Matthew Harris, Martin Smith and Iva Rosic – and they are all excellent. All three of them would be in my top five lawyers in Auckland for a reserve brief.’

Key clients

ANZ Bank


Genesis Energy Ltd


PwC


SkyCity Entertainment Group


Vector Ltd


Kiwi Property


Royal Forest and Bird Protection Society of New Zealand


AFT Pharmaceuticals Limited


Winton


Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei Whāi Rāwa


Work highlights


  • Acted for a2 Milk in a ground-breaking application to have a New Zealand class action stayed in favour of an existing Australian action.
  • Acting for the distributor of an aluminium composite panel product that is one of three defendants to a proposed class action alleging the product is “combustible”, failed to comply with fire safety standards, and is not fit for purpose.
  • Acting for one of the defendants to the prosecution by the New Zealand health and safety regulator, WorkSafe, following the Whakaari White Island eruption killing 22 people in December 2019.

Russell McVeagh

Russell McVeagh is praised for its ‘exceptional’ ability to ‘take complex legal issues and distil down clear and concise advice to be able to guide strategy’. The team is regularly involved in significant high-profile disputes, including large-scale class actions and contentious matters, across a wide range of sectors. The practice is steered by Kirsten Massey, who is a highly experienced commercial litigation and dispute resolution specialist, with particular expertise in class actions, financial services litigation and professional negligence disputes. Key contact Malcolm Crotty is a trusted adviser for critical and strategic litigation matters, while the ‘impressive’ Marika Eastwick-Field is noted for her contentious and advisory expertise in M&A, banking and financial services, capital markets, property, and leasing disputes. Nathaniel Walker has a proven track record in all levels of the New Zealand court system and routinely receives instructions at the top of the market.

Practice head(s):

Kirsten Massey


Other key lawyers:

Marika Eastwick-Field; Malcolm Crotty; Chris Curran; Nathaniel Walker


Testimonials

‘More than anything else, Russell McVeagh’s capability and client service sets them apart. There’s no doubt that, for our most complex and high-value disputes, there’s no firm we’d want advising us more than Russell McVeagh.’

‘The team’s ability to take complex legal issues and distil down clear and concise advice to be able to guide strategy (in a way that makes sense to all internal stakeholders) is exceptional.’

‘Russell McVeagh’s disputes team are top of their field from an expertise perspective, but their real value is in the understanding of our goals, and the wider industry in which we operate.’

‘They really take the time to understand our business and drivers behind any dispute, and are always conscious of all the implications across the business of any dispute or potential disputes.’

‘Marika Eastwick-Field is impressive. While she is obviously experienced and knowledgable, she is also a pleasure to work with, is very engaged, timely and communicative regarding costs incurred.’

‘Marika Eastwick-Field understands our business and in particular understands and works within the framework of our position on each matter.’

‘The team are extremely commercial and pragmatic, and anticipate client needs very well.’

Key clients

Omni Bridgeway


ASB Bank Limited


Winton Property Investment Limited


Woolworths Group


AIA International


KPMG


Calibre Partners


Toka Tū Ake EQC


Westpac Banking Corporation


Tiger Brokers (NZ) Limited


Bank of New Zealand


Work highlights


  • Acting for the Crown entity that provides natural disaster insurance to New Zealand residential homeowners in four separate class actions arising out of its role in providing natural disaster insurance following the Canterbury Earthquake Sequence in 2010–2011, one of New Zealand’s (and the world’s) largest ever natural disaster events.
  • Assisting Omni Bridgeway with a high-profile class action on behalf of building owners against manufacturers and distributors of combustible cladding.
  • Representing AIA, New Zealand’s largest life insurer, in proceedings brought by the Financial Markets Authority for alleged breaches of the “fair dealing” provisions in the Financial Markets Conduct Act 2013.

Wilson Harle

Wilson Harle is a specialist litigation firm that fields a ‘very talented’ team of individuals and is praised for its ‘high-quality service’. Based in Auckland, clients turn to the team for its wide-ranging capabilities in commercial disputes, public law litigation, regulatory cases, defamation claims, and media disputes. Chris Browne has more than four decades of experience as a litigation lawyer, and is noted for his broad commercial litigation and public law practice. Allison Ferguson is recommended for her experience in handling matters arising from directors’ obligations, media law, telecommunications, regulatory matters, and negligence, while Ian Denton‘s practice includes contract, tortious, and trade practices disputes. Lauded for her ‘timely, insightful and pragmatic’ advice, Felicity Monteiro works on a broad range of commercial and civil disputes, including regulatory matters, complex contractual disputes, trust-related mandates, and white collar crime. Guy Tompkins is also recommended.

Practice head(s):

Chris Browne; Allison Ferguson; Ian Denton; Felicity Monteiro; Guy Tompkins


Testimonials

‘Small boutique litigation firm that is comprised of very talented individuals that provide high-quality service.’

‘Stand out partners who I have worked with as counsel are Felicity Monteiro, Alison Ferguson and Ian Dent.’

‘Felicity Monteiro provides timely, insightful and pragmatic advice. I’d recommend her highly for all commercial dispute resolution, litigation or regulatory investigation support matters.’

Key clients

Former Directors of Intueri Education Group


Maungaiti Limited and Maungaiti Trustee Company Ltd


VideoTaxi Ltd


New Zealand Retail Property Group Limited


Napier City Council


Body Corporate 207624


Living Streets Aotearoa


Winton Land Limited


One NZ


Public Trust


Ecomi Technology PTE Limited


Wikeley Family Trustee Limited


Gambling Commission


Martin Cooper and Cooper & Co Real Estate Limited


Serious Fraud Office


Auckland Regional Public Health Service


Wi Te Tau Huata and Donna Huata


C&R Construction


Work highlights


  • Represented the NZRPG group of companies, as plaintiffs, in the 8-week trial of a significant claim against Auckland Council and Auckland Transport for contractual breaches relating to the parties’ joint project to design and construct Westgate Town Centre, the third largest metropolitan centre in Auckland.
  • Acted for the Body Corporate of the Spencer on Byron apartment tower in a successful High Court proceeding alleging professional negligence against its former solicitors, Grimshaw & Co.

Duncan Cotterill

Spread across the firm's Auckland, Wellington, Nelson, Christchurch, and Queenstown offices, Duncan Cotterill is well-positioned to advise its domestic and international client base on regulatory, commercial IP, employment, and insurance-related disputes. Jonathan Scragg co-leads the practice from the Wellington office and is noted for his expertise in commercial, insurance, and public law disputes. Practice co-leader Ayleath Foote is based in the Christchurch office, and is noted for her work in highly sensitive matters and her specialism in trust-related disputes. Brian Nathan is a key port of call to insurers seeking assistance on claims and regularly defends prosecutions under health and safety legislation, while Tanya Wood is recommended for her expertise in insurance, construction, and cyber litigation.

Practice head(s):

Jonathan Scragg; Ayleath Foote


Other key lawyers:

Rob Coltman; Brian Nathan; Olivia Lund; Tanya Wood


Testimonials

‘National coverage. Experts in dispute resolution and insurance. Accessible. Good to deal with.’

‘The Wellington litigation team is led by an experienced practitioner, who is a safe pair of hands to have on your side in a dispute.’

‘For our region, they are large, but also have a national footprint. Plenty of IP within the wider network. A good mix of friendly staff who go the extra mile, including the non-professional staff. They appear to be leading edge with technology in the legal setting.’

Key clients

Lego


Serco


Wilson Parking


PGG Wrightson


Wintrust New Zealand Ltd


Winton Property Investments Ltd


Prime Property


Te Whatu Ora


New Zealand Nurses Organisation


ISO Ltd


Fee Langstone

Noted for its ‘deep understanding of the insurance industry and insurance law’, Auckland-based Fee Langstone is variously praised for its ‘friendly, formidable, practical and reliable’ advice. The practice counts complaints, regulatory investigations, and class actions in its key caseload. The team is jointly led by the ‘truly outstanding’ Philippa Fee and Craig Langstone. Fee regularly represents insurers and their clients in property damage claims, while Langstone is routinely engaged by insurance companies in dispute resolution matters. The ‘client-focused’ Russell Stewart is noted for his expertise in professional indemnity litigation, defending claims against solicitors and barristers, accountants, investment bankers, and engineers.

Practice head(s):

Philippa Fee; Craig Langstone


Other key lawyers:

Pauline Davies; Russell Stewart; Matthew Atkinson; Virginia Wethe


Testimonials

‘Very strong team of capable lawyers with a deep understanding of the insurance industry and insurance law.’

‘All in all, we have found the team at Fee Langstone always friendly, formidable, practical and reliable. We have found their service to be exemplary.’

‘Philippa Fee was amazing. She gave great practical advice right from the outset and was available when urgently needed with fantastic support. The support throughout was great and her skill at wrapping it up when it needed to be resolved was perfect. Truly outstanding.’

‘Russell Stewart is client focused and provides practical advice and litigation support in a cost-efficient manner.’

‘Fee Langstone have a formidable team of lawyers who are able to listen to its clients, understand the client’s issues, which are often complex, then advise on the matters in hand within a reasonable timeframe.’

‘Russell Stewart knows his audit litigation more than anybody I have ever met.’

‘Fee Langstone are exceptional litigators. They always kept me well informed and ensured that what they were providing was what my business needed. They are knowledgeable and practical. Excellent value for money.’

‘Russell Stewart is client-focused and provides practical advice and litigation support in a cost-efficient manner.’

Key clients

Crombie Lockwood


EY


Frank’s International


KPMG Ireland


KPMG New Zealand


Lloyds of London


NCI Commercial Collections


NTI Limited


PricewaterhouseCoopers


QBE European Operations


QBE Insurance (Australia) Ltd


NZI & NZI Marine


Vero Insurance (Suncorp)


Zurich New Zealand


Work highlights


  • Acted for Ernst & Young in relation to High Court proceedings brought by Fuji Xerox NZ and related entities against its former auditor, EY, two former directors and the former CFO arising out of alleged inappropriate accounting practices.
  • Representing QBE Insurance (Australia) Ltd and its insured (Statistics New Zealand) in bringing a subrogated recovery action against two engineering firms and the owner/landlord of a building which has been deemed a total loss following the Kaikoura earthquake.
  • Acting for Chapman Tripp in defending High Court class action proceedings in relation to the initial public offering of shares and subsequent collapse of the Intueri Education Group.

Hesketh Henry

Hesketh Henry is well-placed to advise its diverse portfolio of clients on contentious matters in targeted industries, including construction, insurance, employment, trade and transport, and property. The practice is jointly steered by Auckland-based partners Alison Maelzer and Glen Holm-Hansen. Maelzer provides expert advice in all aspects of employment law, with a particular interest in disciplinary issues, while Holm-Hansen has in-depth experience in complex construction litigation. The team has been strengthened by the arrival of senior associate Ariana Stuart who joined from Dentons New Zealand in February 2023.

Practice head(s):

Alison Maelzer; Glen Holm-Hansen


Other key lawyers:

Christina Bryant; Nick Gillies; Helen Macfarlane; Ariana Stuart


Testimonials

‘The team, collectively, has a comprehensive understanding of the law, which is evident through their abilities to analyse and interpret complex legal issues and achieve favourable outcomes for their clients.’

‘The team excels in their communication skills, whether that is presenting compelling arguments to resolve disputes or explaining complex legal issues in an accessible manner.’

‘Nick Gillies has worked closely with us on several complex construction disputes and, in each case, demonstrated a deep understanding of the legal issues and the challenging environment in which our business operates.

‘What sets Nick Gillies apart is his proactive approach to managing expectations and his ability to communicate in a clear and concise manner.’

Key clients

Vero Insurance


Juken New Zealand Ltd


AECOM


Fulton Hogan


Charterers P&I Club


Form Building & Developments


The General Trust Board of the Diocese of Auckland


Russell Group


Savvy Vineyards Group


McConnell Dowell


XPO Exhibitions Ltd


Vestner NZ Ltd and Vestner Aufzuege GmbH


Gensler


Work highlights


  • Represented XPO Exhibitions (New Zealand’s largest exhibition organising company) in successfully obtaining High Court relief in a high-profile matter concerning the well-known Auckland Showgrounds, allowing events and exhibitions to continue there.
  • Representing a New Zealand subsidiary of the SRG Global Group in a procedurally complex, high-value dispute involving every strata of the New Zealand Court system going up to the Supreme Court.
  • Acted for Maritime Mutual Insurance Association (NZ) Ltd in successfully obtaining a permanent anti-suit injunction in respect of a certain vessel, understood to be the first successful anti-suit injunction in New Zealand to enforce an arbitration agreement.

Lane Neave

The litigation team at Lane Neave is praised for its ‘broad range of speciality lawyers’ and ‘very pragmatic’ approach. The practice advises a range of clients, from large companies and publicly owned entities, to smaller businesses and individuals. Spearheading the practice is commercial litigation and insolvency expert Ben Russell, who has been praised for his ‘spot on strategic advice’. Rebecca Scott is noted for her experience in a range of commercial and civil litigation disputes, while new hire James Cochrane (previously at Stace Hammond) has significant banking and finance, insolvency, and insurance experience.

Practice head(s):

Ben Russell


Other key lawyers:

Rebecca Scott; Simon Clay; Hayley McKee; Mike King; James Cochrane


Testimonials

‘The team have a broad range of skill sets which enable clients to receive very professional and well-determined advice on all issues surrounding and relating to dispute resolution.’

‘We have used this firm for dispute resolution a number of times; they have the requisite skills for this type of work and have always provided advice in a timely manner.’

‘The team at Lane Neave are super flexible and hard working, very pragmatic and insightful about strategy, and very client outcome focussed. I love working with these guys.’

‘Ben Russell provides spot on strategic advice on time and on budget every time.’

‘Both partners have a very clear view and understanding of the challenges faced by our organisation and have provided considerable support and very solid advice across a range of issues.’

‘Rebecca Scott is an excellent team leader, very accomplished in her commercial litigation and hugely hard workers for their clients.’

‘Lane Neave have a very broad range of specialty lawyers covering all aspects and fields.’

‘Good team with relevant experience to the case at hand. Competent, experienced and easy to work with.’

Key clients

PKF Corporate Recovery & Insolvency (Auckland) Limited


Orion New Zealand Limited


Interleasing New Zealand Limited


McMillan Shakespeare Limited


Synlait Milk Limited


Westland District Council


Bathurst Resources Limited


PricewaterhouseCoopers


Trustees Executors Limited


Deloitte New Zealand


BDO New Zealand


CEAS / 151 Insurance Limited


North Ridge Living Limited


Gerry Rea Partners


Khov Jones


Work highlights


  • Advising PwC as liquidators of Genetic Developments (NZ) Exports Limited Partnership, a livestock exporter which collapsed in September 2022 with a shortfall to over 50 farmer creditors of $12m.
  • Representing a client in defending a claim brought by a group of 12 plaintiffs seeking recovery of approximately $4m losses arising from the 2017 Port Hills fires.
  • Acted for Chris McCullagh and Steve Lawrence (PKF) as liquidators of Kaikorai Valley Properties Ltd (In Liq) in bringing a claim against WG Limited Partnership to recover assets for the benefit of the company’s creditors.

Mallett Partners

Mallett Partners has a solid focus on corporate M&A and dispute resolution – on the disputes front, Ollie Gascoigne is a key contact for litigation and arbitration. He is hailed as ‘an excellent lawyer with a keen sense of strategy and an excellent team‘.

Practice head(s):

Ollie Gascoigne


Testimonials

Ollie Gascoigne is an excellent lawyer with a keen sense of strategy and an excellent team’.

Morrison Partners

The ‘tight-knit team’ at Morrison Partners is highly praised for its ability to offer clients ‘practical advice’. The specialist commercial law advisory practice handles a wide range of commercial litigation matters, including appearing in the High Court, Court of Appeal, and Supreme Court. Cameron Fraser heads the practice.

Practice head(s):

Cameron Fraser


Testimonials

‘Tight-knit team delivering top-quality legal services, including practical advice.’

‘The Morrison team is particularly strong in so far as you get leading law firm quality at reasonable prices. The people there are all strong and work in a particularly collaborative way.’

Key clients

Farmers’ Trading Company Limited


StockCo Limited


Mudajaya Group Berhad


Link Business Broking Limited


Wanaka Medical Centre Limited


Evan Williams


Ara Weiti Bay Development Limited


Ara Weiti Development Limited


Ara Weiti Investments Limited


Warkworth Retail Group Limited


Tompkins Wake

Fielding a ‘strong’ dispute resolution team and praised for its ‘good depth of talent and the ability to handle almost any matter’, Tompkins Wake offers advice to clients in disputes relating to dairy industry regulation, insurance, property, aviation and agribusiness issues. ‘Stand out litigator’ James MacGillivray leads the team and is noted for his expertise in diverse sectors, from aviation and local governance, to the dairy industry. Kate Cornegé, described as an ‘excellent strategist’, specialises in general corporate and commercial dispute resolution.

Practice head(s):

James MacGillivray


Other key lawyers:

Kate Cornegé; Chen Jiang; Fraser Wood; Zandra Wackenier; Stephanie Ambler


Testimonials

‘Tompkins Wake’s litigation team are solutions-focused, strategic and able to deliver client service that offers value without waste.’

‘Kate Cornegé is an excellent strategist and able to move seamlessly between her roles as advocate and strategic adviser.’

‘This is a strong team; it has good depth of talent and the ability to handle almost any matter.’

‘James McGillivray is a standout litigator. Calm, perceptive and patient.’

‘Chen Jiang is a hard working rising talent with an excellent knowledge of the law.’

‘Experienced lawyers, great interpersonal skills, organised and responsive.’

‘Clear communication, attention to detail and teamwork are key strengths.’

‘I really enjoyed working with this team and was impressed at how quickly they grasped detailed operational matters specific to our industry, as well as the quality of their legal advice and advocacy.’

Key clients

IBC Japan Limited


Hamilton City Council


South Waikato District Council


University of Waikato


New Zealand College of Midwives


Work highlights


  • Advising IBC Japan Limited in nine separate High Court proceedings in relation to an application for leave to bring a derivative action, an interim injunction, an interpleader dispute over a $10m fund, a protest to jurisdiction, and a caveat action.
  • Acting for Hamilton City Council in the Environment Court and Land Valuation Tribunal in relation to Public Works Act acquisitions in relation to a major subdivision and development to create 8,000 new homes.
  • Assisting a team of barristers with a class action by NZ College of Midwives and over 1,300 midwives against the New Zealand Ministry of Health.

Wynn Williams

The ‘exceptional’ dispute resolution team at Wynn Williams is lauded for its ‘depth within the team’, and ‘good balance of seniors and juniors’. The practice is well-positioned to act for its diverse roster of clients on complex and high-value commercial and civil disputes. Joshua Shaw and Rebecca Saunders jointly steer the practice. Shaw is is noted for his specialist expertise in regulatory and disciplinary prosecutions, while Saunders is recommended for her focus on the construction industry, advising a diverse range of clients from large commercial entities and local government bodies, to contractors and sub-contractors. Key contact Shane Campbell is praised for his ‘impressive grasp of wide areas common law and statutory regulation.’

Practice head(s):

Joshua Shaw; Rebecca Saunders


Other key lawyers:

Greg Simms; Shane Campbell; Andrew Watkins; Josh Taylor; Nick Moffatt; Tim McGuigan; Kate Bradley


Testimonials

‘Wynn William’s Christchurch dispute resolution team, headed by Shane Campbell, is exceptional. They are specialist litigators focused on results.’

‘There is depth within the team, and a good balance of seniors and juniors. ’

‘Shane Campbell is an outstanding lawyer with an impressive grasp of wide areas of common law and statutory regulation. Shane is particularly incisive at developing arguments, and is not afraid to advance cutting edge litigation.’

Key clients

Guoco Group and Brierley Investments


Auto Net / Autoterminal International


Claridges Organics New Zealand Limited


Pacific Auto Carrier (NZ) Limited


Hyung Sum Kim, Rockwell E&C Limited, Rockwell One Limited


Anglican Church of Aotearoa New Zealand and Polynesia


Smart Environmental Limited


Hall’s Group Limited


Redwood Group Limited


Work highlights


  • Acting for Guoco Group and Brierley Investments in a professional negligence claim against PwC in relation to tax losses of NZ$640 million.
  • Advising and representing developers on a $20m building defect dispute.
  • Representing the Anglican Church before the Royal Commission of Inquiry into Abuse in Care.