Set Profile > Chambers of Mark Sutton QC > London, England

Chambers of Mark Sutton QC
Old Square Chambers
10-11 BEDFORD ROW
LONDON
WC1R 4BU
England

Employment Tier 1

Old Square Chambers' 'expertise in employment law issues is second to none and it has good coverage at all levels', say instructing solicitors, who also note how members are 'very knowledgeable about the NHS and the health sector'. Mark Sutton QC represented the appellant in the Agarwal v Cardiff University regarding the scope of the Employment Tribunal's jurisdiction in unpaid wages claims. Among Lord Hendy QC's highlights was the high-profile gig economy case of R (IWGB) v Central Arbitration Committee and RooFoods in which a judicial review was sought on the grounds that denial of the opportunity for Deliveroo couriers, who have been found to not be workers, to bargain collectively is a breach of Article 11 of the European Convention on Human Rights.

Leading Juniors

Stuart Brittenden - Old Square ChambersRare breed of barrister who is extremely good both legally and also in dealings with clients.
Ranked: Tier 1
Melanie Tether - Old Square ChambersHer knowledge of collective complaints such as TUPE, protective awards and redundancies, is excellent.
Ranked: Tier 1
Louise Chudleigh - Old Square ChambersShe has a terrific eye for detail, huge levels of application and is a true expert in the field of equal pay.
Ranked: Tier 2
Nadia Motraghi - Old Square ChambersAlways one step ahead, and great with clients as well as lovely to deal with and very fast turnaround.
Ranked: Tier 2
Katharine Newton - Old Square ChambersA brilliant junior; hardworking, resourceful, great strategic and tactical wisdom.
Ranked: Tier 2
Rebecca Tuck - Old Square ChambersPersonable, works well with clients and has good insight into anticipating a tribunal panel's questions and direction.
Ranked: Tier 3
Spencer Keen - Old Square ChambersA preferred counsel for disability discrimination cases with an ability to advance complex argument in a persuasive form.
Ranked: Tier 3
Eleena Misra - Old Square ChambersWorks tirelessly, quickly grasps the key issues in a case and has a fantastic client manner.
Ranked: Tier 3
Ijeoma Omambala - Old Square ChambersHer strengths lie in her ability to engage with claimants and clearly explain legal concepts and tribunal process.
Ranked: Tier 3
Deshpal Panesar - Old Square ChambersVery clear thinking and able to get right to the heart of the matter very speedily.
Ranked: Tier 3
James Chegwidden - Old Square ChambersHis written arguments are excellent and he has a way of marshalling complicated issues with tremendous force.
Ranked: Tier 4
Betsan Criddle - Old Square ChambersShe has a formidable courtroom presence and is particularly strong in both her written and oral advocacy.
Ranked: Tier 4
Sarah Keogh - Old Square ChambersShe is eloquent before the court and has a very good manner with clients and the other side.
Ranked: Tier 4
Jack Mitchell - Old Square ChambersExtremely user friendly and possesses an encyclopaedic knowledge of whistleblowing law.
Ranked: Tier 4
Nicola Newbegin - Old Square ChambersExceptionally bright barrister, who is forensic in reviewing and understanding the matter at hand.
Ranked: Tier 4

Leading Silks

Lord Hendy QC - Old Square ChambersHe is a Rolls-Royce amongst the senior echelons of the Bar.
Ranked: Tier 2
Oliver Segal QC - Old Square ChambersExtremely clever silk and formidable opponent, who has emerged as one of the leading silks for trade unions.
Ranked: Tier 2
Mark Sutton QC - Old Square ChambersWith a calm exterior he holds court and will sway the bench towards his submissions.
Ranked: Tier 2
Ben Collins QC - Old Square ChambersHis advocacy is always perfectly paced and structured, easy to follow but forensic in detail.
Ranked: Tier 3
Ben Cooper QC - Old Square ChambersHighly intelligent, an excellent cross-examiner and very much on top of the details in a particularly fact-heavy case.
Ranked: Tier 4
Michael Ford QC - Old Square ChambersHe has a real love and an academic’s command of the detail of employment law which he combines with focused and determined advocacy.
Ranked: Tier 4

Personal injury, industrial disease and insurance fraud Tier 3

The 'impressive' Old Square Chambers is an 'excellent choice' in the personal injury market. The set has a longstanding reputation in successfully acting for claimants but has recently built a significant defendant presence. Members, particularly juniors, are highly-regarded for bringing 'different strengths to the table'. Paul Rose QC has extensive experience of acting for severely injured service personnel, which is also an area of expertise for Ben Collins QC, one of the leading experts on the law of criminal injuries compensation. Charles Woodhouse is noted for his proven track record acting for defendants in chronic pain and mild traumatic brain injury claims.

Personal injury - Leading Juniors

Katherine Howells - Old Square ChambersFirst-class preparation and leaves no stone unturned.
Ranked: Tier 2
Christopher Walker - Old Square ChambersGood client care and an excellent grasp of issues in high value cases.
Ranked: Tier 3
Charles Woodhouse - Old Square ChambersBrilliant on his feet and commands respect from the court room.
Ranked: Tier 3
David Rivers - Old Square ChambersHe identifies strengths and weaknesses immediately and brings courtroom insight.
Ranked: Tier 4
Brian Cummins - Old Square ChambersStraightforward and develops a good rapport rather than being confrontational to get the best result for his client.
Ranked: Tier 5
Christopher Edwards - Old Square ChambersExcellent depth of knowledge, approachable and prepared to take a chance where others won't.
Ranked: Tier 5
Charlie Sparling - Old Square ChambersHe remains level headed when presented with difficult situations to manage.
Ranked: Tier 5
Bella Webb - Old Square ChambersAble to explain complex issues in a clear manner. She is a skilled negotiator, taking a robust approach when required.
Ranked: Tier 5

Personal injury - Leading Silks

Paul Rose QC - Old Square ChambersAchieves great results for clients in high value maximum severity brain and spinal cord injury claims.
Ranked: Tier 2
Ben Collins QC - Old Square ChambersVery good with clients and technically strong.
Ranked: Tier 3

Professional disciplinary and regulatory law Tier 3

At Old Square Chambers, Mary O’Rourke QC represented Dr Shekhar Chandra in an appeal brought by the General Medical Council before the Court of Appeal regarding a Medical Practitioners Tribunal's decision to restore Dr Chandra to the medical register after he was struck off for misconduct. The case concerned whether the test for restoring doctors to the register was parallel to the test for restoring solicitors, although the test must still focus on the overriding objective to protect, promote and maintain the public's health and safety. In July 2019, after the matter was remitted to tribunal, the tribunal reaffirmed the decision to restore Dr Chandra to the register.

Leading Juniors

Nadia Motraghi - Old Square ChambersVery experienced in representing healthcare professionals before their regulators.
Ranked: Tier 3
Giles Powell - Old Square ChambersA decisive and steadfast advocate.
Ranked: Tier 3
Betsan Criddle - Old Square ChambersWell known for representing medical professionals in disciplinary cases.
Ranked: Tier 3
Eleena Misra - Old Square ChambersExtremely hardworking and empathetic.
Ranked: Tier 4
Nicola Newbegin - Old Square ChambersShe has astute technical skills and a meticulous eye for detail.
Ranked: Tier 4

Leading Silks

Mary O’Rourke QC - Old Square ChambersAn incredibly clever tactician.
Ranked: Tier 2
Mark Sutton QC - Old Square ChambersA silk with a very clear and measured advocacy style.
Ranked: Tier 3

Clinical negligence Tier 4

The 'impressive' Old Square Chambers is well-established in the clinical negligence field and members are instructed in a wide ranger of cases for both defendants and claimants. Ben Collins QC successfully represented the claimant in Asante v Guy’s & St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust, a complex claim for inadequate management of sickle cell anaemia.

Leading Juniors

Charles Woodhouse - Old Square ChambersA sublime advocate who commands respect in the court room.
Ranked: Tier 3
Victoria Webb - Old Square ChambersShe is a good advocate who has the ear of the court.
Ranked: Tier 4

Leading Silks

Ben Collins QC - Old Square ChambersHe has a very detailed and analytical approach to the evidence.
Ranked: Tier 4
Mary O'Rourke QC - Old Square ChambersShe is an incredibly clever tactician who impresses courts.
Ranked: Tier 5
David Wilby QC - Old Square ChambersHe is a straightforward advocate with good judgement as to the outcome of cases.
Ranked: Tier 5

Clinical negligence

Old Square Chambers is experienced in clinical negligence work from both claimant and defendant perspectives, with particular expertise in birth injury cases, where Kara Loraine and Sophie Beesley have a substantial track record. In addition, Beesley's involvement in the the clinical negligence sphere goes beyond her work on claims, having been appointed as sole counsel to the Ian Paterson Inquiry, which seeks to learn lessons and improve procedures following the conviction of the former surgeon.

Leading Juniors

Sophie Beesley - Old Square ChambersA force to be reckoned with in the courtroom or in negotiation.
Ranked: Tier 2
Kara Loraine - Old Square ChambersRecommended for negligent obstetric care, delayed diagnoses, and fundamental dishonesty claims.
Ranked: Tier 2
Naomi Rees - Old Square ChambersA specialist in clinical negligence matters.
Ranked: Tier 2

Employment

Old Square Chambers is home to several specialist employment barristers, providing good coverage across all aspects of employment law. Whistleblowing specialist Jack Mitchell acted as junior to Simon Gorton QC in the Supreme Court case Royal Mail Group Ltd v Jhuti, in addition to representing both respondents and claimants in several separate tribunal cases also concerning whistleblowing.

Leading Juniors

Spencer Keen - Old Square ChambersParticularly recommended for cases involving complex legal analysis.
Ranked: Tier 1
Toby Kempster - Old Square ChambersBrings a highly strategic and pragmatic approach to cases.
Ranked: Tier 1
Jack Mitchell - Old Square ChambersPossesses an encyclopaedic knowledge of whistleblowing law.
Ranked: Tier 1
Kara Loraine - Old Square ChambersAn enthusiastic and conscientious counsel who is unafraid to roll her sleeves up and get stuck in.
Ranked: Tier 2
Andrew Midgley - Old Square ChambersHis professional manner and style helps to put the client at ease.
Ranked: Tier 2
Melanie Tether - Old Square ChambersA silk in the form of a junior. She has successfully acted for UNISON and it. She is excellent at getting to the crucial point in a matter.
Ranked: Tier 2
Hilary Winstone - Old Square ChambersRecommended for discrimination law cases.
Ranked: Tier 2

Leading Silks

Michael Ford QC - Old Square ChambersHe combines an academic’s command of the detail of employment law with focused and determined advocacy.
Ranked: Tier 1

Employment

Old Square Chambers is home to whistleblowing expert Jack Mitchell, whose notable recent cases include Royal Mail Group v Jhuti, which has progressed to the Supreme Court - the case concerned the test to be applied when the actions of a co-worker can be considered to be an action of the employee in a whistleblowing case.

Leading Juniors

Jack Mitchell - Old Square ChambersPossesses an encyclopaedic knowledge of whistleblowing law.
Ranked: Tier 1

Personal injury

Old Square Chambers is home to a strong contingent of personal injury juniors, with experience of complex, multi-track cases on behalf of claimant and defendant. Particular areas of specialism include employers liability and high-value road traffic accidents, with the set recently securing a £6.5m settlement for a claimant motorcyclist who had been struck by a car, following two failed mediation attempts.

Leading Juniors

Toby Kempster - Old Square ChambersHis experience and knowledge helps him to provide a great service.
Ranked: Tier 1
David Rivers - Old Square ChambersTechnically excellent and incredibly thorough.
Ranked: Tier 1
Christopher Walker - Old Square ChambersForensically astute and brilliant with clients.
Ranked: Tier 1
Charlie Woodhouse - Old Square ChambersHis advocacy is sublime and he has full command of the courtroom.
Ranked: Tier 1
Kara Loraine - Old Square ChambersRecommended for multi-track cases, particularly those involving employers.
Ranked: Tier 2
Sophie Beesley - Old Square ChambersLeaves no stone unturned to secure the best results for her client.
Ranked: Tier 3

Public law

Old Square Chambers is home to Nadia Motraghi, who specialises in public law cases involving NHS trusts and other medical bodies, both at the advisory stage and in judicial review proceedings.

Leading Juniors

Nadia Motraghi - Old Square ChambersPractical, thorough, and knowledgeable.
Ranked: Tier 1

Set overviews: England and Wales

The ‘impressiveOld Square Chambers is ‘an excellent personal injury set’ and ‘one of the leading employment chambers nationally’. ‘Their expertise in employment law issues is second to none and they have good coverage at all levels, meaning you can always find the right barrister for the case in question,’ said one solicitor. The ‘capable, efficient, and helpful’ clerks’ room provides ‘a service-orientated approach and goes above and beyond in trying to ensure you have the right barrister for the job; you have the utmost confidence in the clerking. The team is led by senior clerk William Meade, who ‘is excellent, approachable, leads by example, and he works hard to ensure the practice runs smoothly’. Deputy senior clerk Graham Smith is ‘accommodating and works hard to find alternative counsel if there is a diary clash’; he and Olivia Moliterno are the ‘standout performers’ in the team. Senior team leader Paul Adams is also of note. Senior clerking assistant Jenny O’Grady, team leader Joe Kallas, and junior team leader Lee Jennings are ‘thoroughly helpful and professional to deal with, and transparency on fees is another strength’. Also of note is marketing manager Phil Desmondez. Offices in: London and Bristol

Regional Bar > South Eastern Circuit > Employment

Old Square Chambers is home to whistleblowing expert Jack Mitchell, whose notable recent cases include Royal Mail Group v Jhuti, which has progressed to the Supreme Court - the case concerned the test to be applied when the actions of a co-worker can be considered to be an action of the employee in a whistleblowing case.

Leading Juniors

Jack Mitchell - Old Square ChambersPossesses an encyclopaedic knowledge of whistleblowing law.
Ranked: Tier 1

 

Old Square Chambers (www.oldsquare.co.uk) is widely respected as one of the leading sets for employment and personal injury law, both in London and Bristol. Further specialisms include professional discipline, clinical negligence, environment, health and safety, product liability, motor defence, public inquiries, and mediation/ADR.

The set: Old Square Chambers has over 79 members including 14 silks. It is known for being unstuffy, responsive in understanding client needs and pro-active in meeting them. It adopts the highest standards of advocacy, drafting, advice and client service and is well known for having an excellent clerking team.

Types of work undertaken:

Employment: Old Square is a leading set in employment law with a strong respondent/defendant practice as well as maintaining its longstanding claimant/union practice. It is instructed increasingly in High Court matters and injunctions while developing its well established reputation for expertise in discrimination, equal pay and industrial relations. It has been instrumental in establishing recent legal precedents on fees, holiday pay and discrimination.

Personal injury: Old Square members are regularly instructed in cases concerning high-value head, brain and spinal injury. It has particular expertise in disaster litigation, industrial disease, complex multi-party actions and injuries suffered abroad (including those involving package holiday regulations and the Ministry of Defence).

Clinical negligence: Old Square members have extensive experience in claims relating to cerebral palsy, brain damage and catastrophic injuries. These regularly involve high-value awards of several million pounds. Members have acknowledged expertise in periodic payments and indexation.

Professional discipline: Old Square is at the forefront within a variety of sectors, including healthcare, legal services, education, financial services, police and sport. Members frequently appear before, chair and sit as legal assessors on disciplinary tribunals at all stages of the process, including safeguarding rights by recourse to the High Court and the Privy Council. Several of our silks and juniors regularly appear in cases in the Supreme Court, Court of Appeal and High Court.

Environment: Old Square’€™s expertise includes prosecution and defence in the criminal courts, statutory appeals, scientifically complex nuisance and personal injury claims, major group litigation and judicial review. Areas of particular specialism include water law, contaminated land, statutory nuisance, waste management and the application of European law.

Health and safety: Old Square members are frequently involved in health and safety litigation. This can range from client defence in regulatory prosecutions to representing injured, bereaved and dependent clients in public inquiries. Cases are often high-profile, involving serious injury, fatality, and corporate manslaughter. Operating throughout the UK, Old Square has extensive experience in diverse sectors including construction, transport, farming, quarrying, leisure and healthcare.

Product liability: Old Square members are highly experienced in multi-claimant litigation and in individual cases relating to medical appliances, motor vehicles, cosmetics, toys and other consumer goods. Members also undertake Consumer Protection Act and related prosecutions and product recall.

Public inquiries: Old Square members have been instructed in most of the significant inquires of recent years, drawing on their expertise in health and safety and industrial relations law in public inquires concerned with major accidents or disasters. These include: Leveson, Potters Bar, Ufton Nevert Train Crash, Mubarek, Shipman, Climbie, Ladbroke Grove, Marchioness, Southall Train Crash, North Wales Child Abuse and Bristol Royal Infirmary.

Mediation: as accredited CEDR mediators, Old Square members regularly act as neutral evaluators in a wide range of disputes, particularly employment law, discrimination, personal injury and clinical negligence.

Pupillage: Old Square offers outstanding training to outstanding candidates in both London and Bristol. Reflecting their interests and supportive in approach, this training carries an excellent chance of tenancy and we have an outstanding retention record of keeping pupils.

 

Department Name Email Telephone
Senior clerk William Meade
Clerks Graham Smith
Clerks Paul Adams
Clerks Jack Wheeler
AdministrationMarketing Sarah Earl
AdministrationMarketing Nicole Hayes
AdministrationMarketing - Bristol Liane Wheeler
Photo Name Position Profile
Mr John Bates  photo Mr John Bates
 Sophie Beesley  photo Sophie Beesley
Ms Claire Bowsher-Murray  photo Ms Claire Bowsher-Murray
 Stuart Brittenden  photo Stuart Brittenden
 Simon Cheetham QC photo Simon Cheetham QC
 James Chegwidden  photo James Chegwidden
 Louise Chudleigh  photo Louise Chudleigh
Mr Ben Collins QC photo Mr Ben Collins QC
Mr Ben Cooper QC photo Mr Ben Cooper QC
 Betsan Criddle  photo Betsan Criddle
 Brian Cummins  photo Brian Cummins
 David Cunnington  photo David Cunnington
 Christopher Edwards  photo Christopher Edwards
 Corinna Ferguson  photo Corinna Ferguson
 Hannah Freeman  photo Hannah Freeman
 Katherine Fudakowski  photo Katherine Fudakowski
 Stephen Garner  photo Stephen Garner
Mr Tom Gent  photo Mr Tom Gent
 Simon Gorton QC photo Simon Gorton QC
 Stephen Grime QC photo Stephen Grime QC
 Lance Harris  photo Lance Harris
Lord John Hendy QC photo Lord John Hendy QC
Ms Katherine Howells  photo Ms Katherine Howells
 Spencer Keen  photo Spencer Keen
 Fran McDonald  photo Fran McDonald
 Jane McNeill QC photo Jane McNeill QC
 Elizabeth Melville  photo Elizabeth Melville
Ms Eleena Misra  photo Ms Eleena Misra
Mr Jack Mitchell  photo Mr Jack Mitchell
 Robert Moretto  photo Robert Moretto
Ms Nadia Motraghi  photo Ms Nadia Motraghi
Ms Nicola Newbegin  photo Ms Nicola Newbegin
Ms Katharine Newton  photo Ms Katharine Newton
 Michael Nicholson  photo Michael Nicholson
Ms Ijeoma Omambala  photo Ms Ijeoma Omambala
 Anya Palmer  photo Anya Palmer
 Deshpal Panesar  photo Deshpal Panesar
 Giles Powell  photo Giles Powell
 Frederic Reynold QC photo Frederic Reynold QC
 David Rivers  photo David Rivers
Mr Paul Rose QC photo Mr Paul Rose QC
 Adam Samuel  photo Adam Samuel
 Ian Scott  photo Ian Scott
 Oliver Segal QC photo Oliver Segal QC
Ms Rosalie Snocken  photo Ms Rosalie Snocken
 Charlie Sparling  photo Charlie Sparling
Mr Mark Sutton QC photo Mr Mark Sutton QC
Mrs Melanie Tether  photo Mrs Melanie Tether
 Rebecca Tuck  photo Rebecca Tuck
 Victoria Webb  photo Victoria Webb
 Bella Webb  photo Bella Webb
 Robin White  photo Robin White
 David Wilby QC photo David Wilby QC
Mr Charles Woodhouse  photo Mr Charles Woodhouse