The Legal 500

Chambers of Sue Carr QC

4 NEW SQUARE, LINCOLN'S INN, LONDON, WC2A 3RJ, ENGLAND
Tel:
Work 020 7822 2000
Fax:
Fax 020 7822 2001
DX:
1041 LONDON CHANCERY LANE WC2
Web:
www.4newsquare.com
Email:

What we say about the set's legal practice in London Bar

Administrative and public law (including local government)

Within Administrative and public law (including local government) Administrative and public law – Leading Silks

Clinical negligence and healthcare

Within Clinical negligence and healthcare Clinical negligence and healthcare – Leading Silks

Construction

Within Construction, Four New Square (Chambers of Sue Carr QC) is a third tier firm,

At Four New Square, Roger Stewart QC has ‘a knack of getting to the crux of issues quickly’, and Ben Patten QC is ‘bright, hardworking and good with clients’. In 2010, it welcomed the arrival of the ‘very strongDavid Sears QC from Atkin Chambers.

Consumer and product liability

Within Consumer and product liability, Four New Square (Chambers of Sue Carr QC) is a second tier firm,

Four New Square is a ‘top-notch, professionally run set’ with standout experience in all areas of consumer and product liability. At silk level, Justin Fenwick QC and Jeremy Stuart-Smith QC have both recently advised on fire claims, including the Buncefield explosion, and David Turner QC specialises in commercial product liability cases. Graham Eklund QC is ‘practical yet very analytical of problems’, and Jalil Asif QC is ‘intelligent, cooperative, and knowledgeable about the discrete areas’. Dr Peter Feldschreiber’s ‘medical qualifications, coupled with his in-depth knowledge of the pharmaceutical industry, give him a unique perspective on life sciences product liability cases’. Also recommended are Professor Eva Lomnicka and Paul Sutherland.

Costs

Within Costs, Four New Square (Chambers of Sue Carr QC) is a second tier firm,

While Four New Square might not have the same number of costs specialists as other sets, in terms of quality, its barristers are ‘clearly premier division . Among them, Nicholas Bacon QC is considered ‘a guru on costs matters’. Roger Mallalieu’s ‘particular strengths lie in bringing clarity and depth to the case and integrating that into a team approach to get the best result’. Timothy Chelmick has ‘an extremely bright mind’ and is an ‘excellent advocate’, with ‘the potential to rise to the top of the profession’.

Fraud: civil

Within Fraud: civil Fraud: civil – Leading Silks

Insurance and reinsurance

Within Insurance and reinsurance, tier 4

The ‘very much up-and-comingFour New Square houses names including Graham Eklund QC, who marries a ‘sound legal approach to a well-tuned commercial antenna’; Mark Cannon QC, who has a ‘cerebral, dry approach’ and whose ‘written work is as good as it gets’; Jeremy Stuart-Smith QC (‘an excellent and polished advocate’); and Nicholas Davidson QC (who ‘displays mastery of the law and practice of insurance’). Junior Jonathan Hough is ‘a first-rate legal brain’.

International arbitration

Within International arbitration International arbitration – Leading Silks

Media, entertainment and sport

Within Media, entertainment and sport,

Four New Square’s Graeme McPherson QC is an ‘invaluable and credible weapon in any sport case’; Richard Liddell is ‘sharp and extremely thorough’; and, ‘well on his way to becoming a leading junior in the field’, Daniel Saoul is one to watch for the future.

Pensions

Within Pensions,

Raquel Agnello QC and Thomas Robinson at 11 Stone Buildings are well versed in handling insolvency and regulatory aspects of pensions cases. Elsewhere, clients praise James Clifford from Maitland Chambers as ‘always providing robust advice’; Nigel Burroughs of Four New Square, for his ‘commercial and pragmatic approach’; and Nicholas Randall at Devereux, who is involved in high-profile cases relating to public sector pensions.

Personal injury

Within Personal injury Personal injury – Leading Silks

Professional discipline and regulatory law (including police law)

Within Professional discipline and regulatory law (including police law) Professional discipline and regulatory law (including police law) – Leading Silks

Professional negligence

Within Professional negligence, Four New Square (Chambers of Sue Carr QC) is a first tier firm,

Four New Square is the ‘leading chambers in the professional negligence arena; it is well clerked and provides a consistently high-quality service’. Leading silks include Justin Fenwick QC, who has ‘excellent client skills’; Nicholas Davidson QC, who is described as ‘a master of cross-examination’; Sue Carr QC, who is ‘adaptable’ and gives ‘prompt, commercial advice’; Jeremy Stuart-Smith QC, who is ‘a true class act’; and Roger Stewart QC, who is ‘peerless’. Graeme McPherson QC is ‘outstanding’, and Ben Hubble QC is ‘absolutely at the top of his game’. The ‘first-rateLeigh-Ann Mulcahy QC and the ‘excellentDavid Turner QC are also singled out. The set fields ‘many standout juniors’, including the ‘helpful, bright and personableFiona Sinclair. Jamie Smith is ‘intellectually very strong’, and Siân Mirchandani provides ‘sensible, commercial and practical advice’. Also recommended are the ‘impressiveClare Dixon; the ‘responsiveHelen Evans; Anneliese Day, who ‘has excellent judgement’; the ‘very hardworkingScott Allen; Richard Liddell, who is ‘intelligent and meticulous’; and ‘budding starCarl Troman.

Property litigation (including agriculture and housing)

Within Property litigation (including agriculture and housing),

Also recommended are: Vivian Chapman QC at 9 Stone Buildings, who has ‘vast expertise in village green issues’; and David Halpern QC of Four New Square. Of the juniors, Ranjit Bhose’s knowledge of landlord and tenant matters is ‘up there with the very best’ at 2-3 Gray’s Inn Square; and Paul Letman of 3 Hare Court is ‘very well versed in enfranchisement legislation’. The ‘very brightPatrick Rolfe at 5 Stone Buildings is also recommended. Recent moves include the 'exceptionalJeremy Cousins QC (formerly of Selborne Chambers) joining 11 Stone Buildings. At Field Court Chambers, Miles Croally and Adrian Davis are highly regarded.

Treasury Panel Lists

Within Treasury Panel Lists Junior Counsel to the Crown – C Panel


Legal Developments in the UK

Legal Developments and updates from the leading lawyers in each jurisdiction. To contribute, send an email request to
  • HOUSING

    In Nzinga Maswaku v Westminster City Council [2012] EWCA Civ 669 the Court of Appeal clarified that in offering a homeless person with alternative temporary accommodation the local authority is obliged to point that if the offer is refused it has discharged its Part VII duties under the Housing Act 1996.
    - 11KBW
  • COUNCIL TAX

    In Harrow LBC v Ayiku [2012] EWHC 1200 (Admin) Sales J held that the word “or” in the Council Tax (Exempt Dwellings) Order 1992, art 3 Class N, had a disjunctive meaning, therefore it was sufficient for the non-British spouse of a foreign student to satisfy one or other of the two conditions, namely being prevented from taking paid employment or being prevented from claiming benefits, in order to qualify as a “relevant person” who was exempted from liability to pay council tax.
    - 11KBW
  • QUEEN’S SPEECH

    Bills already introduced pursuant to the Queen’s Speech on 9 May 2012 include Local Government Finance Bill and Electoral Registration and Administration Bill, both accompanied by Explanatory Notes, which in each case address ECHR compatibility.
    - 11KBW
  • Standards

    In R (Calver) v Adjudication Panel for Wales [2012] EWHC 1172 (Admin) Mr Calver was a member of Manorbier Community Council who successfully challenged the decision of the Panel to dismiss his appeal against a decision by Prembrokeshire County Council Standards Committee censuring him for a number of comments or blogs posted by him on a website he owned and controlled.
    - 11KBW
  • A justified retrospective

    Clive Sheldon - QC debates the pros & cons of retrospective tax legislation
    - 11KBW
  • Public Sector Equality Duty (“PSED”)

    In R (Greenwich Community Law Centre) v Greenwich LBC [2012] EWCA Civ 496 the Court of Appeal held that the Council had had “due regard to the PSED when making changes to its funding of community legal advice services”. At para 30 Elias LJ said:
    - 11KBW
  • Public Sector Equality Duty

    Surrey County Council conducted a review of its Library Service. This culminated in a Report to the Council’s Cabinet. The Recommendations in the Report included that there should be consultation about a community-partnership approach at selected Libraries.
    - 11KBW
  • Judicial Review

    The Judgment of Lindblom J in The Manydown Co Ltd v Basingstoke and Deane BC [2012] EWHC 977 (Admin) repays attention. The Claimant sought to challenge by judicial review 2 decisions of the Council: (1) the Council’s refusal to reconsider its position on the development of a site that it owns (and is the subject matter of a Joint Development Partnership Agreement with the Claimant); and (2) a decision of the Council’s Cabinet approving a selection of sites for development which did not include this site.
    - 11KBW
  • The Health and Social Care Act 2012: impact on adult social services

    After its torrid passage through Parliament, the Health and Social Care Bill received Royal Assent on 27 March 2012. The Act deals principally with healthcare reform, but it also contains some amendments to the legislative framework for social care. It will come into force on a day yet to be appointed by the Secretary of State.
    - 11KBW
  • Immigration update May 2012

    In this issue: