The Legal 500

25A WESTERN AVENUE, MILTON PARK, ABINGDON, OXFORDSHIRE, OX14 4SH, ENGLAND
Tel:
Work 01235 836600
Fax:
Fax 01235 836700
DX:
144160 ABINGDON-4
Web:
www.bsdr.com
Email:

Philip Shaw

Tel:
Work 01235 836652
Email:
BrookStreet des Roches LLP

Work Department

Dispute resolution.

Position

Head of dispute resolution. Philip has 25 years experience of dealings with commercial and real estate disputes at all levels of the judicial hierarchy and in all forms of dispute resolution including litigation, arbitration and adjudication and is a qualified mediator having completed an accredited course with ADR Group in March 1996. Philip has a particular interest in professional negligence involving solicitors, surveyors, architects and accountants. He also undertakes judicial review work, principally in the retail sector. Some of the reported cases he has been involved in are set out below: National Grid Company Plc v M25 Group Limited [1998] All England Reports (D) 791 – rent review and third party determination provisions in a lease did not confer on an expert the exclusive power to construe it; Nurdin and Peacock Plc v DD Ramsdon & Co [1999] All England (D) 112 – overpayments of rent made in the mistaken belief they were due and owing could be recovered as money paid by mistake, whether the mistake was one of fact or law; Fenton v Holmes [2007] All England ER (D) 12 – solicitor found negligent arising out of failure to spot an agricultural tie; R (on the application of The Midcounties Cooperative Limited) v Forest of Dean DC [2007] EWHC 1714 – the adequacy of reasons to be given as part of a planning permission for an edge of town superstore (the court found the reasons were inadequate); R (on the application of The Midcounties Cooperative Limited) v Wyre Forest District Council (1) and Tesco Stores Ltd (2) [2010] EWCA Civ 841 – challenge to the right of a retailer to build a superstore on the outskirts of an historic town; Kama Aviation Company Ltd v Zaher Nicola Jeries Deir (1) and Jet Connections Ltd (2) [2010] EWHC 1276 (QB) – commission claim commission arising from the sale of a Boeing 737 aircraft in complex commercial arrangements with a Saudi Sheikh. Net judgment of more than $130,000 in favour of the agent; and Zaher Nicola Jeries Deir v Fahad Bin Saleh Mohammed Al Athel and Others [2011] EWHC 354 (QB) – acting in further ‘acrimonious litigation’ relating to director’s fees including various counterclaims with net judgment of over £250,000 in favour of the claimant.

Career

Trained Allan Janes & Co; qualified 1988; Linnells (now Blake Lapthorn), partner 1991; partner and head of dispute resolution BrookStreet des Roches LLP 1994 to date.

Member

Property Lawyers Association (PLA); Professional Negligence Lawyers Association (PNLA).

Education

The John Hampden Grammar School; Kingston University (LLB 1985); College of Law, Guildford (Solicitors Finals 1986).

Leisure

Golf, skiing, spinning, watching rugby.

Practice Areas

Litigation - commercial; Professional negligence; Property - litigation

Back to index

Legal Developments worldwide

Legal Developments and updates from the leading lawyers in each jurisdiction. To contribute, send an email request to
  • http://www.drewnapier.com/Publications-Events/Legal-Updates/Copyright-(Amendment)-Bill-2014

    This update discusses the Copyright (Amendment) Bill 2014 (" Bill "), which was passed by Parliament on 8 July 2014.
  • EU/AT: Austrian gas law's possible non-compliance with EU Gas Directive

    On 18 July 2014, the Austrian energy regulatory authority E-Control released its affirmative decision in relation to the certification of Trans Austria Gasleitung GmbH (" TAG ") as a transmission system operator (" TSO ") for gas. In its decision, E-Control not only requires TAG to be comprehensively restructured, but also takes a stance on the European Commission's (" EC ") opinion on the potential non-compliance of the Austrian Natural Gas Act 2011 (Gaswirtschaftsgesetz " GWG ") with EU unbundling rules.  read more...
  • Proposals to enhance regulatory safeguards for investors in the capital markets

    This update discusses a consultation paper published by the Monetary Authority of Singapore on proposals to enhance its regulatory framework for safeguarding investors' interests. The proposals are in the following three key areas: (a) extending to investors in non-conventional investment products the current regulatory safeguards available to investors in capital markets; (b) requiring investment products to be rated for complexity and risks, and for these ratings to be disclosed to investors; and (c) refining the non-retail investor classes including providing accredited investors the option to benefit from the full range of capital markets regulatory safeguards that are applicable for retail investors.
  • New Regulation for the Turkish Banking Industry: Towards a Healthy Synthesis Between the Banks and t

    Turkish banking industry is considered one of the strongest in Europe. The crisis ridden global banking industry had experienced numerous difficulties following the 2008 market collapse, but Turkish banking industry had survived the crisis with relatively insignificant scars.
  • A Touchstone in Energy Financing: Reduced Yield and Turkish Insurance Market

    The effect of climate change is not only an environmental problem today as it directly relates to the resource based industries.  In today's world, the scientific assessments lead the players of energy to reflect on their project viability.  In direct proportion to the growth in financing renewable projects, insurance companies and underwriters are also expected to formulate their risk assessments on resource-oriented allocation models.  Since especially the incontestable growth of ancillary instruments in Europe and  the Japan the warranties in financing the "energy as the capital and the resource itself" yields new insurance coverage.
  • UA: New rules for conversion of FX proceeds

    The National Bank of Ukraine (NBU) introduced the compulsory exchange of 100% of foreign currency proceeds.  read more...
  • Competiton Law Quarterly Update Q2/2014

    In this edition's feature article "CCS airline industry market study", we discuss CCS findings from an airline industry market study which CCS commissioned to examine whether certain joint ventures between airlines operating through Singapore have actually resulted in net economic benefits.
  • South Korea: Draft Act on Compensation and Relief of Environmental Pollution Damage

    The Korean Government has launched a government project to establish a system to compensate and insure against environmental pollution damage, and is pursuing the introduction of a legal relief system for environmental pollution damage. Such Government initiative is intended to address the current situation where environmental pollution accidents inflict serious damage on society due to the enormous amount of tax money that is required for curing the pollution, while companies that caused the accident sometimes go bankrupt because they cannot bear the financial burden of paying the compensation. Moreover, the victims of environmental pollution accidents are often unable to obtain proper compensation due to the burden of proving that their injury resulted from the pollution or due to the prolonged litigation process which is unavoidable in light of the nature of environmental pollution.
  • South Korea: KFTC Approves First Consent Decree

    On March 12, 2014, the Commissioners of the Korea Fair Trade Commission ("KFTC") approved a consent decree with Korea's major Internet portal companies, Naver and Naver Business Platform (collectively "Naver") and Daum Communications ("Daum"). This was the first time since its introduction that a consent decree was used to conclude a case before the KFTC. With this consent decree, the KFTC's investigation of Naver and Daum for their alleged abuse of market dominance ended without any finding of liability.
  • South Korea: Recent Developments in Broadcasting Regulations

    Recent regulatory developments in the ever-changing broadcasting environment are summarized below.