The Legal 500

25A WESTERN AVENUE, MILTON PARK, ABINGDON, OXFORDSHIRE, OX14 4SH, ENGLAND
Tel:
Work 01235 836600
Fax:
Fax 01235 836700
DX:
144160 ABINGDON-4
Web:
www.bsdr.com
Email:

Philip Shaw

Tel:
Work 01235 836652
Email:
BrookStreet des Roches LLP

Work Department

Dispute resolution.

Position

Head of dispute resolution. Philip has 25 years experience of dealings with commercial and real estate disputes at all levels of the judicial hierarchy and in all forms of dispute resolution including litigation, arbitration and adjudication and is a qualified mediator having completed an accredited course with ADR Group in March 1996. Philip has a particular interest in professional negligence involving solicitors, surveyors, architects and accountants. He also undertakes judicial review work, principally in the retail sector. Some of the reported cases he has been involved in are set out below: National Grid Company Plc v M25 Group Limited [1998] All England Reports (D) 791 – rent review and third party determination provisions in a lease did not confer on an expert the exclusive power to construe it; Nurdin and Peacock Plc v DD Ramsdon & Co [1999] All England (D) 112 – overpayments of rent made in the mistaken belief they were due and owing could be recovered as money paid by mistake, whether the mistake was one of fact or law; Fenton v Holmes [2007] All England ER (D) 12 – solicitor found negligent arising out of failure to spot an agricultural tie; R (on the application of The Midcounties Cooperative Limited) v Forest of Dean DC [2007] EWHC 1714 – the adequacy of reasons to be given as part of a planning permission for an edge of town superstore (the court found the reasons were inadequate); R (on the application of The Midcounties Cooperative Limited) v Wyre Forest District Council (1) and Tesco Stores Ltd (2) [2010] EWCA Civ 841 – challenge to the right of a retailer to build a superstore on the outskirts of an historic town; Kama Aviation Company Ltd v Zaher Nicola Jeries Deir (1) and Jet Connections Ltd (2) [2010] EWHC 1276 (QB) – commission claim commission arising from the sale of a Boeing 737 aircraft in complex commercial arrangements with a Saudi Sheikh. Net judgment of more than $130,000 in favour of the agent; and Zaher Nicola Jeries Deir v Fahad Bin Saleh Mohammed Al Athel and Others [2011] EWHC 354 (QB) – acting in further ‘acrimonious litigation’ relating to director’s fees including various counterclaims with net judgment of over £250,000 in favour of the claimant.

Career

Trained Allan Janes & Co; qualified 1988; Linnells (now Blake Lapthorn), partner 1991; partner and head of dispute resolution BrookStreet des Roches LLP 1994 to date.

Member

Property Lawyers Association (PLA); Professional Negligence Lawyers Association (PNLA).

Education

The John Hampden Grammar School; Kingston University (LLB 1985); College of Law, Guildford (Solicitors Finals 1986).

Leisure

Golf, skiing, spinning, watching rugby.

Back to index

Legal Developments worldwide

Legal Developments and updates from the leading lawyers in each jurisdiction. To contribute, send an email request to
  • Abuse of Dominance on Dependent Companies under Turkish Commercial Code

     
  • The Latest Tax Amnesty in Turkey: Law No 6552

    Turkish parliament has enacted the Law No: 6552 that has been promulgated as of September 11, 2014 and provides restructuring for unpaid tax debts and administrative penalties. 
  • Pitfalls in Financing the Renewable Investments in Turkey

    In 2012, OECD has reported that economy-wide transformation will require cumulative investment in green infrastructure in the range of USD 36-42 trillion between 2012 and 2030, i.e. approximately USD 2 trillion or 2% of global GDP per year. Today more less is being invested annually. Therefore, a remarkable investment gaps exist that needs to be addressed.
  • Dominance - Greece 2014

    Overview of the main recent developments addressing issues of abuse of dominance in Greece. Latest application of article 2 of Law 3959/2011 (equivalent to 102 TFEU) by the Hellenic Competition Commission and the Greek courts.  dominance_2014_greece
  • European Antitrust Review - Greece 2014

    Presentation of the Greek legal framework on the protection of free competition (L.3959/2011), which generally follows articles 101, 102 TFEU and the framework of EU Regulation 1/2003. The chapter presents recent law changes, as well as the trends in Greek antitrust practice, together with an overview of the most significant cases brought before the Hellenic Competition Commission and the Greek Courts.  ear_greece_2014
  • Public Competition Enforcement Review - Greece 2014

    Presentation of last year's enforcement by the Hellenic Competition Commission (‘HCC'). A brief overview of the most interesting developments in the area of Greek competition law, including recent antitrust cases examined by the HCC and the Greek courts.  greece_2014
  • Listed stock options and warrants - The Ruling Commission has fixed certain conditions

    The so-called "Ruling Commission" sets the conditions under which listed options enter into the scope of the law of 26 March 1999. This is an important decision regarding the exemption from social security of such options.
  • Land Allocation for Renewable Market in Turkey

    Turkey aims to utilize its energy potential, including renewable sources in a cost-effective manner. Today, Turkey targets the share of renewable resources in electricity generation to be at least 30 % by 2023. To meet this, current incentive mechanism for renewables relies on feed-in tariff mainly in solar and wind power. Numbers of renewable energy projects have been increasing since 2010 in Turkey.  After energy revolution in 2010, remarkable deals have been substantiated in the last years. There have been several projects pending before administrative authorities to be approved. However, numbers of the projects are still not at the desired level. 
  • Procurement Mechanism in Turkish Defense Industry-I

    In the field of defense industry, a new system of governance has been established through the Law#3238 ratified in 1985 in order to realize planning and coordination, taking quick decisions and execution (especially for  imports, exports, modernization, research and development, mutual trade, finance) in the government of highest level. Also the basic aim of law is explained as the development of a modern defense industry and ensuring the modernization of the Turkish Armed Forces.
  • Trade secret - controversies

    Jurisprudence has provided two different decisions in identical case matter, namely the contracting authority's right (or the lack thereof) to disclose information regarded as a trade secret by the economic operator. The regional court in Łódź decided in 2004 that the contracting authority is bound by the economic operator's stipulation regarding confidentiality of some of the information contained in the offer. It may accept it or may reject the offer, but it has no right to disclose it. In 2005 the Supreme Court of the Republic of Poland declared something completely to the contrary in its resolution: the contracting authority has the right to disclose information which does not satisfy statutory conditions of a trade secret. Is the Supreme Court right and does its resolution constitute the final word in this matter? In my opinion, the resolution in fact only raises more doubts.