The Legal 500

Twitter Logo Youtube Circle Icon LinkedIn Icon

BTO Solicitors LLP

ONE EDINBURGH QUAY, 133 FOUNTAINBRIDGE, EDINBURGH, EH3 9QG, SCOTLAND
Tel:
Work 0131 222 2939
Fax:
Fax 0131 222 2949
DX:
ED77 EDINBURGH
Email:
Web:
www.bto.co.uk
Edinburgh, Glasgow

Paul Motion

Tel:
Work 0131 222 2932
Email:
BTO Solicitors LLP

Work Department

Data Protection, Technology & IP, Intellectual Property, Media & Entertainment, Commercial Dispute Resolution, Public Law, Human Rights Law, Planning and Judicial Review.

Position

Partner and Solicitor Advocate 

32 years qualified, a versatile and highly experienced civil Solicitor Advocate who has used his Rights of Audience continuously and prominently since 1998. Has conducted his own cases, been led by Senior Counsel, and led junior Solicitor Advocates. A recognised expert in Data Protection and contentious IT/IP, he has run many ground breaking cases, for example, the only successful UK appeal against a Data Protection Monetary Penalty (£250k - Scottish Borders Council -v- ICO). He has two active court cases seeking distress compensation under the Data Protection Act 1998. He ran the first Scottish case on minority shareholder “derivative actions” (Wishart -v- Castlecroft); a judicial review seeking a Protective Expenses Order (Newton Mearns Flood Prevention Group); was instructing agent in the first appeal against a Planning Local Review Body (Carroll -v- Scottish Borders Council) and acted as Solicitor Advocate in an eight-day trial involving contentious public procurement (Aquatron). He represents clients in ADR such as mediations, arbitrations, domain name proceedings and trade mark proceedings. In June 2014, he conducted a mediation involving seven parties which ran for 20 hours. In 2012, he ran a Court of Session case and simultaneously presented complaints to Nominet and WIPO under the DRS and ICANN-UDRP disputes procedures, relating to domain names for ‘payday loan’ websites. Paul is presently conducting a complex arbitration involving a Spanish time-share resort. He is presently acting for the trade mark owner in contested trade mark cancellation proceedings. Over many years he has carried out several "Dawn Raids" in commercial and IP cases (e.g. Apex Chemicals). He has conducted numerous cases involving urgent interdict (injunction) orders, such as internet harassment, IP infringements, breaches of restrictive covenants, trade mark infringement, passing-off and theft of confidential information/trade secrets.

Almost uniquely in Scotland, Paul is equally at home with non-contentious IT/IP work including contracts, software development agreements, SLAs and licensing. In 2015 he was part of the team representing a cloud provider which was a tender bidder to a Scottish university, in a full-day Competitive Dialogue meeting that discussed the bidder’s proposal and the University’s proposed contracts. He is also one of a small number of Scottish solicitors who deal with music recording and production contracts, as well as artist management contracts.

Career

Partner, BTO Solicitors LLP (2006 - present); Partner, Ledingham Chalmers (1999 – 2006); Solicitor, Fyfe Ireland WS (1995-1999); Solicitor, Steedman Ramage WS (1994-1995); Solicitor, Bell Gully, Auckland NZ, (1990 – 1993), Solicitor, Dundas & Wilson CS (1986 – 1990), Solicitor Allan McDougall & Co (1984 – 1986), Trainee, Shepherd & Wedderburn WS (1982 – 1984).

Memberships:

Convenor of the Law Society of Scotland's Technology Committee (2000 – 2016); Board Member (2009 – 2011) and immediate past Chairman (2005 – 2011) of the Scottish Society for Computers and Law; Immediate Past Civil Vice President of the Society of Solicitor Advocates (2010 – 2011); [Secretary 2002 – 2010]. Member of the Society of Writers to Her Majesty’s Signet 2004.

Director of Recycle to Cycle Limited t/a The Bike Station.

Regular contributor to national and legal press in relation to technology issues since 2000. Since 2009, Paul has appeared at Edinburgh Fringe presenting three ‘shows’ annually dealing with copyright matters, aimed at artist managers, writers, producers and venue managers. Has given several BBC Radio interviews about internet law and social media.

Member

Law Society of Scotland; convenor Law Society of Scotland’s Technology Committee; past board member and chairman Scottish Society for Computers and Law; Society of Solicitor Advocates; Society of Writers to Her Majesty’s Signet 2004.

Education

Kirkcaldy High School; Aberdeen University (1981 LLB; 1982 Dip LP; 1984 NP).

Leisure

Scottish Regional Representative for 'Vulcan to the Sky' aircraft preservation project (2010-2015); asked to fulfil same role for VTTS’s new project to return a Canberra bomber to flight (2016); Scottish and Northern Area Representative of Avro Shackleton Return to Flight project (2015 – date); running half marathons, DIY.


Scotland: TMT (technology, media and telecoms)

Intellectual property

Within: Intellectual property

BTO Solicitors LLP advises on commercialisation agreements and design rights litigation. Paul Motion represented The Door Company in a web domain dispute.

[back to top]

Media and entertainment

Within: Media and entertainment

At BTO Solicitors LLPPaul Motion advises claimants on defamation matters regarding social and traditional media, as well as on press regulation issues.

[back to top]


Back to index

Legal Developments worldwide

Legal Developments and updates from the leading lawyers in each jurisdiction. To contribute, send an email request to
  • New Industrial Property Law

    The Industrial Property Law abrogating the patchwork of decrees that governed intellectual and industrial property rights has been published in the Official Gazette and entered into force on January 10, 2017.
  • Cross-shareholding Rules and Dividend Tax Exemptions Clarified

    19 Apr 2017 at 04:00
  • Labour E-Contract

    On 13 December 2016, the Ministry of Administrative Development, Labor and Social Affairs (MADLS) of the State of Qatar Read more..
  • Privatization of Domestic Coal-Fired Power Plants in Turkey

    The privatization tender of Çayırhan-2 coal reserve area and the construction of a coal-fired power plant project (“Çayırhan-2 Project ”) was concluded on February 6, 2017, which has been the first of the new wave of privatization of coal reserves and construction of lignite coal-fired power plants in Turkey in line with the recent incentives regarding utilization of domestic coal reserves for electricity generation. This client alert outlines the main novelties in relation to this new wave of lignite-fired power plant tenders, which is expected to continue with several other privatizations in 2017 as explained below.
  • Important Changes to the Electricity Market Licensing Regulation

    On February 24, 2017, the Energy Market Regulatory Authority (“EMRA ”) published a Regulation (“Amending Regulation ”) containing important changes to the Electricity Market Licensing Regulation (“Licensing Regulation ”), including the removal of the share transfer restriction at the pre-license period for transfers to foreign companies and foreign-capital companies, and changes related to the Renewable Energy Resource Areas (“YEKA ”). Highlights of major changes are as follows:
  • The New ICC Arbitration Rules

    As of 1 March 2017, the new Arbitration Rules of the International Chamber of Commerce (“New ICC Rules ”) have come into effect and superseded the former version of the ICC arbitration rules, which have been in effect since 2012.
  • Information law for company participants – the search for a balance of interests

    At the present time, in various legal relationships there exists the acute problem of observing a balance of interests concerning the parties involved in these legal relationships, their legal rights, and their mutual economic needs. Judicial practice, when considering disputes between these kinds of parties, takes into consideration not only the formal requirements of legislation, but also the real economic and legal goals and interests of the participants.
  • Cyprus: Changes To The Inheritance Process Under European Succession Regulation 650/2012

    The growing importance of cross border successions within the European Union and the difficulties and complications resulting from the diversity of succession and private international law rules relating to succession, prompted the European Commission to examine the possibility of introducing a Regulation that would facilitate and streamline cross border successions.
  • A fight against corruption by the proposed introduction of Criminal Record Certificates for Companie

    Due to existing problems with regards to companies competing for the undertaking of public projects, on the 28 th  September 2015 the Cabinet decided to give an end to the scandals involving the squander of millions of public money by approving an amendment Bill, which would add to the conditions for public tenders, the requirement of providing a Criminal Record Certificate for legal entities. Until today, this was not required due to gaps and loopholes in the existing Law. Provided this Bill will be passed into Law by its publication at the Official Gazette of Cyprus, companies applying for public tender will be asked to produce a certificate that would show they have a clean criminal record.
  • Innovation & Thailand 4.0: Value Creation for Business using Trade Secrets

    Thailand 4.0 stands for the new stage to transform the country currently relying on heavy industries (3.0 stage) into a creativity and innovation-driven economy. Trade secrets are definitively value-based and could help pursing Thailand 4.0.