The Legal 500

Twitter Logo Youtube Circle Icon LinkedIn Icon

BTO Solicitors LLP

ONE EDINBURGH QUAY, 133 FOUNTAINBRIDGE, EDINBURGH, EH3 9QG, SCOTLAND
Tel:
Work 0131 222 2939
Fax:
Fax 0131 222 2949
DX:
ED77 EDINBURGH
Email:
Web:
www.bto.co.uk
Edinburgh, Glasgow

Paul Motion

Tel:
Work 0131 222 2932
Email:
BTO Solicitors LLP

Work Department

Data Protection, Technology & IP, Intellectual Property, Media & Entertainment, Commercial Dispute Resolution, Public Law, Human Rights Law, Planning and Judicial Review.

Position

Partner and Solicitor Advocate 

32 years qualified, a versatile and highly experienced civil Solicitor Advocate who has used his Rights of Audience continuously and prominently since 1998. Has conducted his own cases, been led by Senior Counsel, and led junior Solicitor Advocates. A recognised expert in Data Protection and contentious IT/IP, he has run many ground breaking cases, for example, the only successful UK appeal against a Data Protection Monetary Penalty (£250k - Scottish Borders Council -v- ICO). He has two active court cases seeking distress compensation under the Data Protection Act 1998. He ran the first Scottish case on minority shareholder “derivative actions” (Wishart -v- Castlecroft); a judicial review seeking a Protective Expenses Order (Newton Mearns Flood Prevention Group); was instructing agent in the first appeal against a Planning Local Review Body (Carroll -v- Scottish Borders Council) and acted as Solicitor Advocate in an eight-day trial involving contentious public procurement (Aquatron). He represents clients in ADR such as mediations, arbitrations, domain name proceedings and trade mark proceedings. In June 2014, he conducted a mediation involving seven parties which ran for 20 hours. In 2012, he ran a Court of Session case and simultaneously presented complaints to Nominet and WIPO under the DRS and ICANN-UDRP disputes procedures, relating to domain names for ‘payday loan’ websites. Paul is presently conducting a complex arbitration involving a Spanish time-share resort. He is presently acting for the trade mark owner in contested trade mark cancellation proceedings. Over many years he has carried out several "Dawn Raids" in commercial and IP cases (e.g. Apex Chemicals). He has conducted numerous cases involving urgent interdict (injunction) orders, such as internet harassment, IP infringements, breaches of restrictive covenants, trade mark infringement, passing-off and theft of confidential information/trade secrets.

Almost uniquely in Scotland, Paul is equally at home with non-contentious IT/IP work including contracts, software development agreements, SLAs and licensing. In 2015 he was part of the team representing a cloud provider which was a tender bidder to a Scottish university, in a full-day Competitive Dialogue meeting that discussed the bidder’s proposal and the University’s proposed contracts. He is also one of a small number of Scottish solicitors who deal with music recording and production contracts, as well as artist management contracts.

Career

Partner, BTO Solicitors LLP (2006 - present); Partner, Ledingham Chalmers (1999 – 2006); Solicitor, Fyfe Ireland WS (1995-1999); Solicitor, Steedman Ramage WS (1994-1995); Solicitor, Bell Gully, Auckland NZ, (1990 – 1993), Solicitor, Dundas & Wilson CS (1986 – 1990), Solicitor Allan McDougall & Co (1984 – 1986), Trainee, Shepherd & Wedderburn WS (1982 – 1984).

Memberships:

Convenor of the Law Society of Scotland's Technology Committee (2000 – 2016); Board Member (2009 – 2011) and immediate past Chairman (2005 – 2011) of the Scottish Society for Computers and Law; Immediate Past Civil Vice President of the Society of Solicitor Advocates (2010 – 2011); [Secretary 2002 – 2010]. Member of the Society of Writers to Her Majesty’s Signet 2004.

Director of Recycle to Cycle Limited t/a The Bike Station.

Regular contributor to national and legal press in relation to technology issues since 2000. Since 2009, Paul has appeared at Edinburgh Fringe presenting three ‘shows’ annually dealing with copyright matters, aimed at artist managers, writers, producers and venue managers. Has given several BBC Radio interviews about internet law and social media.

Member

Law Society of Scotland; convenor Law Society of Scotland’s Technology Committee; past board member and chairman Scottish Society for Computers and Law; Society of Solicitor Advocates; Society of Writers to Her Majesty’s Signet 2004.

Education

Kirkcaldy High School; Aberdeen University (1981 LLB; 1982 Dip LP; 1984 NP).

Leisure

Scottish Regional Representative for 'Vulcan to the Sky' aircraft preservation project (2010-2015); asked to fulfil same role for VTTS’s new project to return a Canberra bomber to flight (2016); Scottish and Northern Area Representative of Avro Shackleton Return to Flight project (2015 – date); running half marathons, DIY.


Scotland: TMT (technology, media and telecoms)

Intellectual property

Within: Intellectual property

BTO Solicitors LLP advises on commercialisation agreements and design rights litigation. Paul Motion represented The Door Company in a web domain dispute.

[back to top]

Media and entertainment

Within: Media and entertainment

At BTO Solicitors LLPPaul Motion advises claimants on defamation matters regarding social and traditional media, as well as on press regulation issues.

[back to top]


Back to index

Legal Developments worldwide

Legal Developments and updates from the leading lawyers in each jurisdiction. To contribute, send an email request to
  • New requirement for all issuers operating on the Luxembourg Stock Exchange

    On 10 August 2017 the Luxembourg Stock Exchange announced that all domestic and foreign issuers operating on the regulated market (Bourse de Luxembourg) or on the multilateral trading facility (Euro MTF) of the Luxembourg Stock Exchange must provide their legal entity identifier (“LEI ”) codes to the Luxembourg Stock Exchange before 15 September 2017.
  • Luxembourg law on the exploration and use of space resources entered into force

    The Luxembourg law on the exploration and use of space resources of 20 July 2017 entered into force on 2 August 2017 and placed Luxembourg among the most innovative space-oriented nations in the world.
  • VAT in the GCC – Q&A updates from the UAE Ministry of Finance

    On 9 July the United Arab Emirates (UAE) Ministry of Finance (MOF) published an update of the Value Added Tax (VAT) FAQ section of its website.
  • PRIIPs KID: The final pieces of the puzzle

    The pieces of the puzzle are finally falling into place. The long-awaited level 3 and 4 measures have been published earlier this week, half a year before the PRIIPs KID becomes compulsory.
  • MiFID II: Further guidance on product governance requirements

    Amongst the numerous topics covered by the Markets in Financial Instruments Directive II (MiFID II), the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) has decided to provide further guidance on the requirements regarding product governance through its guidelines dated 2 June 2017 which focus on the target market assessment by manufacturers and distributors of financial products.     
  • Arendt & Medernach is again the “Luxembourg Tax Firm of the Year”

    The partners of Arendt & Medernach are pleased to announce that their firm has been awarded once again the prestigious “Luxembourg Tax Firm of the Year” title during the International Tax Review’s European Tax Awards ceremony held at the Savoy Hotel in London on 18 May.
  • Signature of the Multilateral instrument – reservations made by Luxembourg

    On 7 June 2017, the official ceremony for the signing of the multilateral instrument (“MLI”) took place bringing to a close a process initiated last year when a consensus was reached on the wording of the MLI on 24 November 2016 (see also our newsflash dated 2 December 2016, available on our website www.arendt.com section Publications/Newsflash).
  • Arendt & Medernach: Luxembourg Law Firm of the Year

    Luxembourg, May 2017 – Arendt & Medernach is proud to have been named “Luxembourg Law firm of the year” both by Chambers & Partners and IFLR (International Financial Law Review). The prestigious trophies were both received in April in London at the respective ceremonies of the Chambers Europe Awards 2017 and the IFLR European Awards 2017.
  • First VAT EU case law on the cost-sharing VAT exemption

    The question of the scope of the cost-sharing VAT exemption, also referred to in the Council Directive 2006/112/EC of 28 November 2006 as amended ("EU VAT Directive") as “Independent Groups of Persons” or “IGPs”, is currently being debated at the Court of Justice of the EU (“CJEU”) in several cases. Last Thursday marked the first milestone regarding this specific VAT exemption since the CJEU released its judgment in the case Commission v Luxembourg (C-274/15).
  • An Introduction to Corporate Guarantee

    In the UAE, the risk management activities inherent in running a corporate or investment banking business remain of crucial importance, not least because of the strong local characteristic of “name lending”, by which is meant lending or providing other banking facilities to family or other private businesses, primarily on the strength of the “name” or “names” of the proprietors standing behind the business, rather than on the strength of the asset quality and underlying credit of the particular business. Of course, in practice, there is commercial overlap between the proprietors and the companies which they own, but the credit analyses can break down where poor banking practices and procedures result in poorly constructed legal documentation and gaps in guarantee and security support documents.