The Legal 500

Twitter Logo Youtube Circle Icon LinkedIn Icon

GRP Rainer LLP

AUGUSTINERSTRAßE 10, 50667 COLOGNE, GERMANY
Tel:
Work +49 221 272 27 50
Fax:
Fax +49 221 272 27 52 4
Email:
Web:
www.grprainer.com
Berlin, Bonn, Cologne, Dusseldorf, Frankfurt, Hamburg and 3 more

Show all Press releases

Breach of confidentiality obligation – Dismissal with immediate effect valid

October 2017

Breach of a confidentiality obligation can justify issuing an employee with notice of dismissal with immediate effect. That was the verdict of the Landesarbeitsgericht (LAG) Baden-Württemberg [Regional Labour Court of Baden-Württemberg] (Az.: 12 Sa 22/16).

We at the commercial law firm GRP Rainer Rechtsanwälte note that before an employer can effectively issue notice of dismissal it needs to assess whether less severe measures such as a formal written warning would be sufficient to prompt the employee to conduct himself in a dutiful manner. Having said that, a ruling of the LAG Baden-Württemberg from November 11, 2016 shows that it is possible to forgo a formal warning if the employee commits a serious breach of duty.

Employees’ duty of confidentiality is particularly important in certain professions, e.g. for doctors and their employees. Patients have a relationship of trust with their doctor and expect that their documents and records will not be shared with third parties without authorization, but this is exactly what happened in the case that came before the LAG Baden-Württemberg. After a patient had cancelled her appointment, a doctor’s assistant took a photo of said patient’s data sheet and sent it to her daughter along with the comment “Mal sehen, was die schon wieder hat” [Let’s see what she’s got this time]. The daughter then showed the message around in her sports club. When the patient’s father learned of this, he complained to the practice and the doctor’s assistant was issued with exceptional notice of dismissal with immediate effect. The duty of confidentiality had been explicitly agreed to in the employment contract. The employer took the view that the doctor’s assistant’s conduct constituted not only a breach of her contractual obligations but also an offence pursuant to sec. 203 para. 3 sent. 2 of the Strafgesetzbuch, Germany’s Criminal Code. It therefore concluded that this represented good cause justifying exceptional notice of the employment relationship’s termination. The doctor’s assistant’s action for wrongful dismissal was unsuccessful. The LAG held that dismissal with immediate effect had been justified, ruling that the employee’s conduct constituted a serious and intentional breach of her duty of disclosure as laid out in the employment contract. It went on to say that maintaining doctor-patient confidentiality, including on the part of non-medical personnel, is fundamental to the relationship of trust required between doctor and patient. The Court stated that the employer had a vested interest in quickly re-establishing this relationship of trust, which meant that it was not reasonable to expect it to continue the employment relationship and a prior formal warning was not necessary. That being said, whether exceptional notice of dismissal is effective is always a decision that is made on a case-by-case decision. Accordingly, it ought to be thoroughly prepared. Lawyers who are experienced in the field of employment law can advise employers. https://www.grprainer.com/en/legal-advice/employment-law.html

Legal Developments by:
GRP Rainer LLP

Legal Developments in Germany

Legal Developments and updates from the leading lawyers in each jurisdiction. To contribute, send an email request to
  • LAG Düsseldorf: Dismissal with immediate effect valid in response to threat

    Anyone who seriously threatens their employer or superior should expect to be dismissed with immediate effect. This was confirmed by a ruling of the Landesarbeitsgericht (LAG) Düsseldorf [Regional Labour Court of Düsseldorf] from June 8, 2017 (Az.: 11 Sa 823/16).
  • Tax evasion: Only voluntary disclosure affords protection from severe penalties

    Anyone who has been caught for tax evasion should expect to be faced with severe penalties. Voluntary disclosure is the only way of returning to a state of normal tax affairs and avoiding penalties.
  • GSK Update: AIFM Marketing in Germany - The clock is ticking for U.S. and other non-EU fund managers

    Our GSK Update informs about the impact of recent German investment fund legislation (UCITS V Implementation Act) for AIF managers, who are not domiciled in the EU (“non-EU-AIFM”) and who seek to market AIF shares in Germany in accordance with applicable German investment fund law under the EU-AIFM Directive (2011/61/EU).
  • GSK expands Luxembourg presence with a new tax partner

    Opened at the beginning of March 2016, GSK Stockmann + Kollegen continues to expand its Luxembourg office. Mathilde Ostertag recently joined the Luxembourg team of Equity Partners Dr. Marcus Peter, Andreas Heinzmann and Dr. Philipp Mößner as Local Tax Partner.
  • EIA - Strengthening the role of the public

    Among other things, the recent amendment to the Environmental Impact Assessment Act has broadened the rights of (what is termed) the "affected public". The affected public consists primarily of various citizens' initiatives pursuing environmental or public-health purposes. It may for instance file an appeal against a negative decision at the screening stage (i.e., a decision according to which the given project does not require the issuance of an EIA report), and seek its annulment in court. The affected public has been granted a stronger voice also in subsequent procedures in which the fate of a building project is being decided: zoning proceedings and the proceedings on the issuance of a building permit. Taken together, these legislative changes may make it more difficult to implement projects which require an EIA report; in particular, the length of permission proceedings may be substantially extended.
  • New Top Level Domains – Noerr expert warns against trademark infringements

    On June 13, the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN) published the names of those who have applied for a new top level domain the ending of which may be geographic, such as "munich", industry identification such as "insurance" and even all trademark names and company descriptions such as "canon" and "adidas".
    - Noerr
  • No obligation to set up filtering systems in order to prevent copyright violations

    ECJ, decision of February 16th, 2012, ref. C-360/10 – SABAM
  • Further ECJ Ruling concerning NGO’s right of action under German environmental law

    For the second time within a short period of time, the non-governmental organisations right to challenge administrative decisions under German law is going to be subject to the jurisdiction of the European Court of Justice (ECJ). In January 2012, the German Supreme Administrative Court (Bundesverwaltungsgericht) referred a case to the ECJ for a preliminary ruling concerning the NGO’s right of action.
  • Lessons in Cross-Border M & A Transactions

    The fundamental advice for international business transactions is obvious and easy to understand: different countries have different laws, business habits and cultures. These differences may range from minor nuances, such as lengthy French business lunches or unusual Spanish office hours, to significant legal roadblocks, such as strict European employment laws.
  • Priority rental rights in insolvency

    Parties to rental contracts for commercial premises often agree priority rental rights. In practice, this concept is used to cover a whole series of legal structures. These range from fixed options for the tenant to a promise made by the landlord as a business policy that if any additional premises become available, they will be offered to the tenant. In 2010 the Berlin Court of Appeal issued a ruling on such priority rental rights in insolvency; the decision has recently been published.