The Legal 500

Twitter Logo Youtube Circle Icon LinkedIn Icon
PRISM TOWER, 19TH FLOOR BUSINESS BAY, BUSINESS BAY, PO BOX 116637, DUBAI, UNITED ARAB EMIRATES
Tel:
Work +971 4 43 57 577
Email:
Web:
www.fichtelegal.com

Show all Press releases

Stranded Sailors Waited 28 Months for this Day

October 2019

A three-year stand-off involving 40 sailors and eight vessels off the UAE belonging to the same company has ended. It followed a long legal battle that saw the Federal Transport Authority (FTA) take action against Dubai-based Elite Way Marine Services. Effective June 6, 2018, the FTA banned the company from all commercial activities and also from operating in the UAE ports and waters.

It was a fight for survival for the sailors who had to live on dwindling supplies of food and water.

“Life in hell is over,” said a relieved Ayyappan Swaminathan as he planted his feet firmly on land for the first time in 28 months.

Till a few weeks ago, land was a distant dream for this Indian captain who, along with his crew, was forced to live on board a run-down commercial vessel off the UAE coast. Unpaid, abandoned and with no regular supply of food and water, they clung on to hope while fighting depression and trauma.

In what could be the end of one of the biggest and long-drawn cases of abandoned vessels off the UAE, Ayyappan and two of his colleagues are finally all set to go home this week.

“My daughter Aniha was five when I embarked on the ship. She is turning eight tomorrow. I want to be home and give her a surprise,” an elated Swaminathan told Khaleej Times.His two colleagues – Rajib Ali from India, who worked as a cook, and chief officer Ibrahim from Sudan – also disembarked from the vessel MV Azraqmoiah on Sunday.

Ayyappan said the company has paid him a major portion of his pending salary, which he claimed was around $8,400. “Our immigration formalities are pending. We just cannot wait to go home.”

Long legal battle

With this, a three-year stand-off involving 40 sailors and eight vessels off the UAE belonging to the same company has ended. It followed a long legal battle that saw the Federal Transport Authority (FTA) take action against Dubai-based Elite Way Marine Services. Effective June 6, 2018, the FTA banned the company from all commercial activities and also from operating in the UAE ports and waters.

As Khaleej Times reported earlier, the Emirati-owned company had abandoned its vessels off the coasts of Ajman, Dubai, Fujairah and Umm Al Quwain after running into debts.

The FTA also appointed legal firm Fichte and Co to represent the sailors. Shehab Mamdouh, a Senior Associate at the firm, said legal action was initiated against the company for not paying the salaries. He said the company owed about $750,000 to the 40 sailors. “Most of the sailors received settlements ranging from 60 to 80 per cent of their outstanding dues.

“We started legal procedures by mid-February this year and then things started moving fast. The first ship was arrested and moved to the port in April, followed by other vessels, and sailors were able to disembark. We are grateful to the FTA for their role in helping the sailors.”

According to Mamdouh, this is one of the biggest cases involving abandoned ships in the UAE. “We haven’t seen a case of this scale and proportion before. It was unacceptable what those men went through. They suffered emotionally and physically. We are grateful that they can finally go home.”

The human cost of the ordeal

It was a fight for survival for the sailors who had to live on dwindling supplies of food and water. The intermittent supply of food from the charity organisation, Mission to Seafarers in Dubai, and the Indian Consulate, was all they could count on during desperate times.

There were days when the men would live in the dark due to power outages on the ship as fuel ran out. Many of the men missed family reunions, marriages and other functions. One sailor, Gurunathan hailing from Tamil Nadu, said he was helpless when his property back home was destroyed in a cyclone. He was stuck in the ship for 18 months with an unpaid salary of about $54,400.

Speaking on the release of the sailors, Andy Bowerman from the Mission to Seafarers, said: “After more than a year of supporting them, we are delighted that the crew of the Azraqmoiah are finally back on shore.”

He said there was one more vessel – The Tamim Aldar – of the Elite Way Marine Services to be brought to shore. “It still has four crew on board and is more than 20 nautical miles from shore. We will continue offering them the same practical and emotional support.”

This article was first published in Khaleej Times on 10th June, 2019

Legal Developments by:
Fichte & Co.

  • Gulf Tanker Attacks: Implications on Costs

    Tanker attacks have a long history indicating that it could be a powerful weapon in international conflict, which can significantly destabilize an economy. During the Iraq-Iran War in the 1980s, oil terminals and tankers were under severe attacks, which directly affected the economies of both nations, in addition to the safety of maritime traffic.
    - Fichte & Co Legal Consultancy

Legal Developments in United Arab Emirates

Legal Developments and updates from the leading lawyers in each jurisdiction. To contribute, send an email request to
  • Regulatory Authorities of UAE Economic Substance Regulations announced

    Further to our previous inBrief dated 7 July 2019, which disucssed UAE Cabinet Resolution 31 of 2019 Concerning Economic Substance Regulations (the UAE Economic Substance Regulations or the Regulations), and inBrief dated 10 October 2019, which discussed the Guidance on UAE Economic Substance Regulations issued by the UAE Ministry of Finance, Cabinet Decision No. 58 of 2019 has now designated the regulatory authorities (the Regulatory Authorities) to regulate compliance with the UAE Economic Substance Regulations. 
  • Emirates Development Bank appointed to maintain Register of Finance Leases

    Pursuant to UAE Federal Cabinet Resolution No. 56 of 2019, Emirates Development Bank has been appointed to maintain the register of finance lease contracts created pursuant to UAE Federal Law No. 8 of 2018 on Finance Lease (the Finance Lease Law or the Law). 
  • UAE Ministry of Finance Issues Guidance on Economic Substance Regulations

    A previous inBrief dated 7 July 2019 discussed UAE Cabinet Resolution 31 of 2019 Concerning Economic Substance Regulations (the UAE Economic Substance Regulations or the Regulations).
  • Gulf Tanker Attacks: Implications on Costs

    Tanker attacks have a long history indicating that it could be a powerful weapon in international conflict, which can significantly destabilize an economy. During the Iraq-Iran War in the 1980s, oil terminals and tankers were under severe attacks, which directly affected the economies of both nations, in addition to the safety of maritime traffic.
  • Funding Your Start-Up In The UAE

    Funding options for start-ups in the UAE are on the rise. Traditionally, most start-ups in the UAE have tended to be bootstrapped or financed by conventional lenders such as banks and financial institutions. However, over the last few years, business incubators and accelerators have flourished in the UAE, creating a conducive and cost-effective environment for entrepreneurship in the UAE. This has led to a gradual upsurge in activities in the angel investment, crowdfunding, private equity, and venture capital space. Notably, the technology space has seen a boost as the UAE government has announced various initiatives for entrepreneurs and has been actively promoting the fintech space.
  • UPDATE: Medical Liability Law in the UAE

    Doctors in the UAE face considerable legal risk when treating patients. Thus, it’s important for casualties as well as medical practitioners to know their rights and get their cases evaluated by legal experts.
  • The New DIFC Employment Law- What Has Changed?

    DIFC Employment Law no. 2 of 2019 (“New Law ”) has recently been enacted which repeals and replaces the DIFC Law no. 4/2005 as amended by DIFC Law no. 3 of 2012 (“Previous Law ”). There has been an ongoing debate about the implemented changes introduced by the New Law. Some changes have been enacted to protect the employers, such as the limitation of liability period of 6 months and the provisions which allow employees to waive their rights under the New Law subject to agreements put in writing. Other changes have been enacted to protect the employees, such as provisions for non-discrimination and non-victimization, the penalties imposed by the DIFC for employer’s non-compliance, and forbidding the employer to retain the employee’s original passport (although the latter was always the legal position in the UAE).
  • UPDATE: New DIFC Wills and Probate Rules

    The DIFC Wills and Probate Registry (WPR) has been established as an official mechanism for non-Muslims to register their wills and have it enforced through the DIFC Courts. Previously there was a lot of uncertainty with regards to the registration of wills of non-Muslims since Shari’a principles govern inheritance throughout the UAE. If an expatriate living in the UAE dies without having a will in place, Shari’a principles will most likely apply, and family members may be forced into an heirship regime without fully understanding the consequences. The best way to ensure certainty over your assets upon death is to register a will with the DIFC WPR. Although the Registry has its own complex rules and laws that would be applicable, it provides a relative freedom of disposition of assets upon death. The DIFC WPR has gone through a number of changes since its establishment in 2015 and has consistently strived to better protect testators and their assets. The DIFC WPR’s jurisdiction has now officially expanded to include assets outside of Dubai.
  • Right of Set off under the UAE Civil Transaction Law No. 5 of 1985 and the view from the DIFC

    In a 2018 judgment the DIFC, discussed and decided upon the concept of set-off under the UAE Civil Transaction Law No. 5 of 1985 (the “Civil Code”).
  • DO FIDIC RULE APPLY IN CONSTRUCTION CONTRACTS IN UAE?

    Since a very long time, FIDIC (The International Federation of Consulting Engineers) is commonly used a standard for international construction and engineering contracts and is very frequently used in UAE. It mainly governs the construction works within the country and in GCC.