The Legal 500

Bardehle Pagenberg

PRINZREGENTENPLATZ 7, 81675 MÜNCHEN, GERMANY
Tel:
Work +49 89 92 80 50
Fax:
Fax +49 89 92 80 54 44
Web:
www.bardehle.com
Email:
Paris, Munich, Milan, Dusseldorf, Barcelona

Show all Press releases

BARDEHLE PAGENBERG successful in a series of Community design invalidity proceedings before OHIM

March 2012

BARDEHLE PAGENBERG has been successful in a series of three Community design invalidity proceedings before the Office for the Harmonisation of the Internal Market (OHIM) in Alicante, Spain (Cases No ICD 8447, 8321 and 8287).

Invalidity proceedings were initiated against Fitness Brands, Inc., Texas, on behalf of Industex SL, a leading TV-marketing company based in Barcelona, represented by BARDEHLE PAGENBERG since 2003.  The accused Community designs had been registered for gymnastics and sports apparatus and equipment showing a fitness device represented by six or seven different views.

BARDEHLE PAGENBERG decided to rely on only one single piece of prior art, i.e., a Chinese design patent registration published prior to the relevant date of application of the accused Community designs.  The Office found the contested Community design new but lacking "individual character" in the sense of Article 6 Community Design Regulation.

This result is an example of the European novelty approach, which is world-wide in scope and without limitation in time, but requires that the circles specialised in the sector concerned in the European Union could reasonably be expected to have known of the prior designs.  Under this approach, prior art may prove to be harmful when challenging a Community design even if the prior design originates from distant jurisdictions, such as China, Japan, Taiwan, Korea etc.  In fact, the Office - the Invalidity Division as well as the Board of Appeal - confirmed repeatedly that publications from these and other countries could be easily searched and, therefore, "reasonably have become known in the normal course of business to the circles specialised in the sector concerned, operating within the Community" (Article 7 [1] CDR).

The decisions are not final.

Representative Industex SL:

BARDEHLE PAGENBERG (München): Dr. Henning Hartwig (Attorney-at-Law, Partner)

Representative Fitness Brands, Inc.:

Patentanwälte Westphal, Mussgnug & Partner (München): Michael Bickel (European Patent Attorney)

OHIM (Invalidity Division):

Dr. Martin Schlötelburg (rapporteur)


For more information please visit www.bardehle.com

Legal Developments by:
Bardehle Pagenberg

Legal Developments in Germany

Legal Developments and updates from the leading lawyers in each jurisdiction. To contribute, send an email request to
  • GSK Update: Proposal for Uniform Protection of Trade Secrets Throughout Europe

    In the information society trade secrets are among the most important assets of any business. The quantity and quality of the trade secrets represent a substantial part of the company's assets. In the European Union there are currently varying levels of protection, insofar as trade secrets are legally protected at all. This hinders cross-border business and companies that operate internationally are faced with legal uncertainty. The EU Commission now wants to change this and has submitted a proposal for a uniform level of protection and protective system across Europe.
  • GSK Newsletter: Taxation of Cross-Border Transactions in Germany

    There are a number of ways how a foreign entity or private individual can pursue business activities in Germany. First, you can become active without creating a physical presence in Germany simply by supplying goods and services to German clients from abroad. Second, the foreign business might establish a fixed place in Germany (e.g. a permanent establishment) from which it pursues its German activities. Third, the foreign business might set up a German subsidiary either as a partnership or as a corporation. Last but not least, collective investment schemes, whose taxation regime has been extensively reorganized recently, might also be an interesting alternative for foreign investors. Which route to follow will mainly depend on the kind and the size of the business activities to be carried out in Germany or with German clients as well as on tax considerations that will have an impact on the decisions to be made. This  GSK Tax Newsletter  shall provide a first introduction to the taxation issues a foreign business considering to expand its activities to Germany will have to take into account. We would be pleased to help you with any questions in this regard!
  • GSK advises 2D Holding GmbH in connection with sale of SÜDDEKOR Group to SURTECO SE

    GSK Stockmann + Kollegen advised 2D Holding GmbH in connection with the sale of SÜDDEKOR Group, a leading specialist in surface finishing of wood materials, to SURTECO SE. On October 23, 2013, 2D Holding GmbH and SURTECO SE entered into a pur-chase agreement regarding the sale of SÜDDEKOR Group consisting of  SÜDDEKOR GmbH in Laichingen, Dakor Melamin Imprägnierungen GmbH in Her-oldstatt, SÜDDEKOR Art Design + Engraving GmbH in Willich, SÜDDEKOR LLC (USA) and Süddekor OOO (Moscow) to SURTECO SE. The transaction was suc-cessfully completed on December 2, 2013 after antitrust release had been obtained. The parties agreed to keep the purchase price confidential.
  • GSK attorneys authored the German Chapter of GTDT's 6th edition of Banking Regulation

    Getting the Deal Through has published the fully revised and updated sixth edition of Banking Regulation, a volume in the series of annual reports, which provide international analysis in key areas of law and policy for corporate counsel, cross-border legal practitioners and business people.
  • Preliminary injunction proceedings in German intellectual property...

    Law & Practice (2013) 8: 136-145
  • GSK attorney Karl v. Hase authored the German Chapter of GTDT’s 10th edition of Dispute Resolution

    Getting the Deal Through has published its fully revised and updated tenth edition of Dispute Resolution, a volume in the series of annual reports, which provide international analysis in key areas of law and policy for corporate counsel, cross-border legal practitioners and business people. Following the format adopted throughout the series, the same key questions are answered by leading practitioners in each of the 47 jurisdictions featured. GTDT's German Chapter was authored by GSK attorney Dr. Karl von Hase. In his article he gives an overview of civil and commercial litigation in Germany, arbitration agreements and alternative dispute resolution (ADR).
  • GSK attorneys authored the German Chapter of GTDT's 5th edition of Banking Regulation

    Getting the Deal Through has published the fully revised and updated fifth edition of Banking Regulation, a volume in the series of annual reports, which provide international analysis in key areas of law and policy for corporate counsel, cross-border legal practitioners and business people.
  • Ownership of employee inventions under the German Law on Employee In-ventions (ArbEG) –

    Potential risks for companies and ways to minimize them
  • Court of Justice of the European Union renders final decision on...

    Supplementary Protection Certificates with regard to second marketing authorization of medical compounds (decision of July 19, 2012 – Case C-130/11 –Neurim Pharmaceuticals vs. Comptroller General of Patents)
  • New Top Level Domains – Noerr expert warns against trademark infringements

    On June 13, the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN) published the names of those who have applied for a new top level domain the ending of which may be geographic, such as "munich", industry identification such as "insurance" and even all trademark names and company descriptions such as "canon" and "adidas".
    - Noerr