Twitter Logo Youtube Circle Icon LinkedIn Icon

United Kingdom > Scottish Bar > Personal injury and clinical negligence > Law firm and leading lawyer rankings



Index of tables

  1. Leading Silks
  2. Leading Juniors

Leading Silks

  1. 1
    • Marion Caldwell QC - Compass ChambersDelivers high-quality advice in an easy-to-understand manner.
    • Angela Grahame QC - Compass ChambersPrepared, approachable, and great at communicating complex issues to lay clients.
    • Lisa Henderson QC - Ampersand AdvocatesHighly numerate, excellent at drafting complex schedules of loss and very personable.
    • Maria Maguire QC - Ampersand AdvocatesCombines superb advocacy skills and a forensic attention for detail.
    • Robert Milligan QC - Compass ChambersPragmatic, decisive and an excellent negotiator.
    • Geoffrey Mitchell QC - Ampersand AdvocatesHighly respected by both health boards and claimant solicitors
    • Douglas Ross QC - Ampersand AdvocatesA relatively new silk who already posesses all the qualities of an experienced one.
    • Lesley Shand QC - Compass ChambersShe has a forensic eye for detail and leaves no stone unturned.
    • David Stephenson QC - Ampersand AdvocatesA superb orator who excels before the court.
    • Lauren Sutherland QC - Ampersand AdvocatesLeaves no stone unturned to find a path to a successful outcome.
  2. 2
    • Simon Bowie QC - Ampersand AdvocatesRecommended for significant clinical negligence cases.
    • Geoff Clarke QC - Compass ChambersRobust and authoritative in negotiation.
    • Una Doherty QC - Ampersand AdvocatesExtremely reliable, quick-witted and efficient.
    • Roddy Dunlop QC - Axiom AdvocatesHe has a strong clinical negligence practice.
    • Iain Ferguson QC - Axiom AdvocatesMeticulous in his preparation and masterful on his feet.
    • Simon Di Rollo QC - Ampersand AdvocatesHighly experienced in industrial disease claims.

Leading Juniors

  1. 1
    • Gordon Balfour - Arnot Manderson AdvocatesRecommended for his work on behalf of defenders.
    • Ewen Campbell - Axiom AdvocatesA thoughtful, thorough and efficient advocate who has an impressive working knowledge of the law.
    • Jamie Dawson - Ampersand AdvocatesFantastic at dealing with complex medical evidence and technical details.
    • Fiona Drysdale - Ampersand AdvocatesWell-prepared, good with clients and has an eye for detail.
    • Nick Gardiner - Arnot Manderson AdvocatesHe has sound general medical knowledge and provides clear and concise advice.
    • Chris Marney - Ampersand AdvocatesA very safe pair of hands with good commercial sense.
    • David McNaughtan - Compass ChambersVery capable and robust in negotiation, while his attention to detail in complex clinical negligence cases is exceptional
    • Graeme Middleton - Compass ChambersAn excellent all-rounder who is comfortable dealing with a wide variety of cases.
    • Astrid Smart - Compass ChambersA stand-out clinical negligence junior who does not give up on a fight easily.
  2. 2
    • Robin Cleland - Compass ChambersA highly capable advocate who excels at handling complex medical and dental negligence cases
    • Brian fitzpatrick - Ampersand AdvocatesAlways willing to get stuck in.
    • Amber Galbraith - Compass ChambersHighly knowledgeable and excellent with clients.
    • Craig Murray - Compass ChambersHis written work is of an impeccably high standard
    • Chris Paterson - Axiom AdvocatesIntellectually astute, with great attention to detail.
    • Barney Ross - Compass ChambersPersonable and charismatic with great negotiation skills.
    • Emma Toner - Compass ChambersDiligent, conscientious and punctual.
    • Helen Watts - Axiom AdvocatesExcellent in court and is very strong in negotiations with opposing parties.

Ampersand Advocates is home to one of the key teams in personal injury and clinical negligence within Scotland, and has 'real strength in depth' across all levels of call. Members have significant expertise in all areas of such work, with recent cases including fatal accidents, medical device litigation, catastrophic injury and birth injury. A notable recent case for the set is Gibson v Babcock International, a leading case on the issue of secondary exposure to asbestos, in which Simon Di Rollo QC led for the pursuers.

Arnot Manderson Advocates is home to a strong team in the fields of personal injury and medical negligence, which acts for both pursuers and defenders in cases involving issues such as catastrophic injury, road traffic accidents and  delayed diagnosis. Of recent note, Nick Gardiner acted for a pursuer seeking reparation following a delay in confirming a diagnosis of cauda equina syndrome.

Axiom Advocates is home to several good clinical negligence practitioners, with a particularly strong presence in matters involving large numbers of claimants as well as surgeon's negligence and failed diagnoses cases. Ewen Campbell and Iain Ferguson QC recently represented the MDDUS in defence almost a thousand claims against a since-struck-off dentist concerning exposure to blood-borne infections.

One of the leading sets in personal injury and medical negligence, Compass Chambers 'provides high quality counsel suitable for cases at any level', with members active across all aspects of the personal injury and clinical negligence spaces. Several members are instructed on high-profile medical devices cases such as the vaginal mesh litigation and the metal-on-metal hip litigation.

International comparative guides

Giving the in-house community greater insight to the law and regulations in different jurisdictions.

Select Practice Area

Press releases

The latest news direct from law firms. If you would like to submit press releases for your firm, send an email request to

Legal Developments in the UK

Legal Developments and updates from the leading lawyers in each jurisdiction. To contribute, send an email request to
  • Court of Justice rules on source of income for Derivative Residence applications

    On 2 October 2019, the Court of Justice delivered its judgment in Bajratari v Secretary of State for the Home Department (Directive 2004/38/EC) Case C-93/18 which concerns Chen applications and the source of funds for self-sufficiency. 
  • End of the ‘centre of life test’ in Surinder Singh cases?

    In the recent case of  ZA (Reg 9. EEA Regs; abuse of rights) Afghanistan   [2019] UKUT 281 (IAC ), the Upper Tribunal found that there is no basis in EU law for the centre of life test, as set out in Regulation 9(3)(a) of the Immigration (European Economic Area) Regulations 2016 (the “Regulations”). It further found that it is not to be applied when Judges assess  Surinder Singh  cases that appear before them.
  • Terms of employment as a sole representative

    In this article we examine the working arrangements of sole representatives, looking at the terms and conditions of employment that the Home Office will expect a sole representative to have in order to qualify as a representative of an overseas business.  
  • Can Sole Representatives Be Shareholders?

    The Immigration Rules require that an applicant for a  sole representative visa  is not “a  majority shareholder in the overseas business”.
  • Immigration Skills Charge - A Guide for Employers

    As a Sponsor, you may be required to pay the Immigration Skills Charge (ISC) each time you sponsor a migrant in the  Tier 2 General  or  Intra-Company Transfer (ICT) Long-term Staff  subcategory.
  • 5 FAQS about paragraph 320(11)

    In applications for entry clearance where the applicant has a negative immigration history in the UK, the application may be refused under the general grounds for refusal, which are found in part 9 of the Immigration Rules. Where an applicant has  ‘previously contrived in a significant way to frustrate the intentions of the Immigration Rules’,  the application could be refused under paragraph 320(11). In this post we look at five frequently asked questions about paragraph 320(11). 
  • Multiple nationality and multiple citizenship (including dual nationality and dual citizenship)

    British nationality law permits multiple nationality and multiple citizenship, including dual nationality and dual citizenship.
  • Applying for Indefinite Leave to Remain in the Exceptional Talent or Promise Category

    The  Exceptional Talent  and Exceptional Promise categories are for individuals who are recognised leaders or emerging leaders in their field of expertise. There are a number of endorsing bodies for lots of different fields of work, including  artists and musicians ,  architects ,  digital experts ,  scientists  and  academics . While there isn’t an endorsing body for every expert, the growing list means that many individuals could enjoy the flexibility that this category has to offer. 

    Syedur Rahmanconsiders the factors that determine when civil proceedings can go ahead before,or at the same time as, criminal proceedings relating to the same circumstances.
  • Rights of appeal after the Immigration Act 2014

    The Immigration Act 2014 (“the 2014 Act”) reduced the circumstances in which the refusal of an immigration application will give rise to a right of appeal. The  explanatory notes  to the 2014 Act state that the Act was intended to restructure rights of appeal to the Immigration Tribunal. Previously, a right of appeal to the Immigration Tribunal existed against any of the 14 different immigration decisions listed in s.82 of the  Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Act 2002  (“the 2002 Act”). As explained below, whether or not the refusal of an immigration application currently generates a right of appeal depends on the subject matter of the application rather than its categorisation.

Press Releases in the UK

The latest news direct from law firms. If you would like to submit press releases for your firm, send an email request to